I honestly don't understand the sentence that you wrote. You might want to construct it properly. I think the gist of your question is this- If there are two pitchers that are equal and one of them has a dad in the stands clocking him, will the coach take the other kid? The answer very easily could be yes if he thinks this is a pattern of a meddling dad.
Coaches want (must have) full autonomy at the college level. They can't have outside influences affecting the structure of the team. That means they can't have parents involved unless it's something that has to do with the student-athlete outside of the team.