Interesting. Many times we hear how common sense should "sometimes" come into play over ruling the rule set. Yet, when it does just as many folks are upset.
Going down the common sense road has the potential to get out of control very quickly. Everyone has the ability to video with their phone. How many judgement calls will be debated with video evidence? "Under the argument that It is a really important game, let's use common sense and allow the video to overturn the outcome."
I think they made the wrong decission. The umps called it correctly. Nothing to overturn. He very well could have missed third. The video is not conclusive. The fact the coach requested the appeal tells me he more than likely missed the bag.