Skip to main content

Hey guys,

I had a lefty pitcher the other day that after coming to a stop, lifted his free foot and held his pose for what seemed like a count of 3 before coming to the plate.  Do you have a balk on that?  In my opinion it was an obvious attempt to deceive the runner.  His free foot never crossed  behind the plane of the rubber.  I called a balk and the manager came out to argue the call.  I told him I what I had and that I would check with you all...but for today,  that move was a balk.  He seemed okay with that explanation...lol.

Thanks as always for your input.

Last edited by JWC1022
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Keep yourself out of trouble - if a coach asks what was done quote to the best of your recollection what the rule indicates.  See 6-2-4d for this one...  Similarly if they fail to stop - it's "no discernible stop, coach" (discernible like beauty is in the eye of the beholder). The other one that's tricky is the 45 degree thing - the best thing to indicate there is failing to step directly toward a base or as some say failing to gain ground toward the base to which you are throwing.

The one our association picked on this year - having the pitching hand down at the side or behind the back because some coach was able to protest that a balk should have been called on a pitcher when he held/hid the ball on his front hip without a balk call and picked off a runner. When questioned, the umpire must've indicated it's legal to keep it there. 

Matt13 posted:

If he began his motion to pitch and came to a complete stop after doing so, that is a balk at all levels.

As an umpire, take "attempt to deceive the runner" out of your vocabulary. There are plenty of legal ways to do so--we only worry about illegal actions by the pitcher.

I completely agree that this should be called a balk.  However when I was watching the WBC championship game Stroman did this several times.  He would just stop his delivery with his leg hanging in the air.  Any reason that this would not be called?  Same with going from stretch to set position, just about every pitcher would hitch 2 or 3 times before coming set.  Why are these things being allowed?

Team Zona posted:
Matt13 posted:

If he began his motion to pitch and came to a complete stop after doing so, that is a balk at all levels.

As an umpire, take "attempt to deceive the runner" out of your vocabulary. There are plenty of legal ways to do so--we only worry about illegal actions by the pitcher.

I completely agree that this should be called a balk.  However when I was watching the WBC championship game Stroman did this several times.  He would just stop his delivery with his leg hanging in the air.  Any reason that this would not be called?  Same with going from stretch to set position, just about every pitcher would hitch 2 or 3 times before coming set.  Why are these things being allowed?

Were there runners on?

Usually in going to the set, there's still something moving. As long as the hitch doesn't interrupt the movement to the set position, it's legal.

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×