As mentioned, you have until Jan 15 for many many good schools (both D1 and D3) that could be good academic and baseball fits. Some schools have even later deadlines. Please consider casting a wider net than the 5 schools you mentioned.
Having been through the process RECENTLY with our older son, a high score, terrific grades, awesome recs, athlete but not recruited, fantastic extra curricular activities and even a "hook" (like the mexican american part but different in our case) - AGAIN, I don't mean to be a negative naysayer here, but even kids with 36s get rejected! The process is really like a lottery at many schools as they can fill their class over many times with kids with nearly perfect scores and grades and such. And the so called "easier" schools often reject such a kid as they think they will get in to a "better" school. There are NO SURE THINGS anymore. Admissions anywhere is just to tough to be certain.