Colton Dixon - he's okay
HeeJune Han - the act is old. He has a nice voice but can't pronounce English words.
Jermaine Jones - he's okay
Joshua Ledet - okay but maybe not mainstream enough
Phillip Phillips - I hate Dave Matthews but I kinda like this guy.
Jeremy Rosado - wild card. Bad choice. Don't like that fake crying and whispering voice.
Denadre - wild card. NO WAY. He's my Sanjaya this year.
Elise Testone - I like her raspy voice.
Hollie Cavanagh - as long as she's not talking in her babyish, lisping, fake English accent (she's from Texas?) she sings great
Jessica Sanchez - liked her a lot after she sang with a sick throat
Shannon Magrane - I think she's the weakest girl but only because she's so young.
Skylar Lane - she's fun. Like the country girls.
Erika Van Pelt - wild card. Good add.
If I had any changes to make I'd have dumped HeeJun, Deandre and Jeremy. I'd rather see Adam "White Chocolate" Brock and Reed Grimm in there.
For the girls, they're much stronger than the guys. But I'd replace Shannon with Jen Hirsch or even Baylie Brown.
Thank goodness they dropped the cute little teeny bopper and the obnoxious NY girl with the even more obnoxious mother.