Would you then include any HS sport? Basketball players, in my experience, also have a lot of ACLs torn. How about the HS baseball player already committed? Would you tell them to forego HS since they have already committed to a collegiate team?
Side note, I had several of my HS players play both football and basketball since I coached at a small HS. One was fortunate to play both football and baseball at U of Iowa. I have had one play basketball and baseball in college.