How about this scenario?? My son's team was very good last year...won their first outright league championship in the history of the school (50 years). They lost a senior pitcher to a D1 school...another very solid pitcher had several D3 offers...and the third was a capable #4 or 5 guy last year. This year, my son is our #1...but also our starting SS and likely 3-hole hitter. Our #2 is also our starting catcher....and #4 hitter. The problems you have when you're a small school and football and basketball are the two most popular sports....