Great debate:
Allow me to rephrase: Choose A or B.
A. HS Catcher has plus arm. Average C&T skills.
B. HS Catcher can flat out receive. Average arm.
I prefer to select B.
Some coaches choose A. since they can teach them to improve C&T.
OBTW: I have also observed a few with neither A. nor B. (and the Dad is convinced his son is draftable his Sr. year!)