Bogeyorpar,
I love the concept. It can bring a lot of value to many people. Where I think the most value can be derived is in the weighting, metrics, and research....my two cents is to let the person driving the tool change the weightings. Everybody's idea of value is very different especially when you start weighting academics and baseball. That can become somewhat of a Holy War, as it does sometimes on HSBBWeb. So, let people assign their own weightings is my feedback. My son is a prime example from that weightings perspective....baseball had very little to do in his decision making whether it was D1 or D3 offers. Baseball offered him leverage and choice with high academic schools. I think with the D3 schools this may be more the case. With the D1 schools it is going to be more about the baseball and the next level.
JMO.