Because of my location, the middle of CT, I am able to see both Jeter and Nomar on a regular basis-- I won't include Arod in this comparison because I have not seen him as I have seen the other two.
Both Derek and Nomar hustle on every play; both are clutch players; both have great egos but are excellent leaders; both are excellent in the field.
I would take either one if they were offered to me as a coach.
Based on A-Rod's stats and history I think he is rates up there with them-- after this season and being able to see all three, especially during the EMPIRE vs Boston games we will see how A-Rod measures up and handles the pressure of the bright lights.
It will be interesting to see what happens and A-Rod, the married man, is seen out late with his buddy Derek. The Bachelor. The NY media will have a field day
The Bright Lights can be tough
Only time will tell
By the way I like the Red Sox to win the AL East--I think their pitching will be the difference and adding a Gold Glove at second base in Pokey is a great move.
TRhit