@JCG posted:All true. The problem with that approach is that if you're a C (or whatever) you probably only have to beat out one or two other guys to get in the lineup. If you're a DH, you have to beat out every non-starter on the team.
Maybe I'm inferring too much from the OP, but the question is - why is dad pushing this? Over the years I've seen parents find many ways to sabotage their son's baseball prospects, and insisting that they be a catcher or an infielder is definitely one of the most damaging -- and stupidest -- ones.
Dad is pushing this because he doesn't know any better and he lacks objectivity. Hopefully, Mom or an Uncle/Aunt knows something about baseball and can help Dad see the light.....