I've been wondering about something - given two catchers which one would you prefer.
Catcher A is great at blocking, 'framing', working with the pitchers, has good baseball sense, etc. but has only a mediocre arm.
Catcher B lets several stoppable balls by him every game and in general isn't as good at the fundamentals, but has a superior arm.
Which catcher would you go with and why?
Original Post