Skip to main content

Reply to "D1 Camp Readiness"

Nope, PF, I don't agree.  Giving a reference to an employer, or telling another church about a bad pastor (presumably on a reference) is not public on the internet.  In fact, aren't most references required to be kept private?  Here, if you want to know, you can ask in a PM, which is private (as far as search engines go).

The same factors don't prevent us from outing schools on this site - of course anyone can do it.  But all the arguments above - cabbagedad's, adbono's, JCG's, etc. - are why it's better for the individual and for the value of HSBBW not to.

Now if a pastor or employee does something criminal and it's in the news, that's different, then they are fair game for public discussion.  Likewise, if the kids at this camp had gone to the hospital and there was a news report about it, we could definitely discuss it by name - and that often happens here.

It was still a great thing to report - anonymously - in a discussion about the value of college camps in recruiting, because it really shows how useless they can be for actually evaluating players.

×
×
×
×