Luring a recruit into a trap means you had serious doubts about that recruit to begin with, good coaches don't do that, good coaches don't even ask those questions, what they want to know is if the team felt if he did or didn't fit in. Now I am not saying that a recruit passing out from going overboard will look good in anyone's eyes, it is more about how you can handle yourself with the temptations of college, and coaches know that can be a challenge in itself.
If passing up alcohol was the deal breaker, I doubt mine would have gone where he did.