David Wright bare hander, Mays of course, Lynn 75 playoffs, Brian Giles going over the wall last year, Rowand into the wall and yes, Matthews' catch were all oustanding. I wouldn't want to have to vote on any of these.
My dad saw Mays play games in the polo grounds. He guessed Mays had to run over 100-125 feet to get that ball and the runway at the grounds was 475 and it was world series catch.