I found that only the ELITE schools required grades above the minimum. And even they reduced their Normal standards for athletes.
Take a look at the fine print of the entrance requirements at several schools Here's one for example from a TOP 25 rated academic school.
quote:We are also very interested in your personal development and background, and we use these elements from the application to increase our understanding of you as a whole person. Consequently, the personal statement forms an integral part of our review process.We consider:
cut...
Exceptional achievements, such as recognition for special talents or extracurricular activities.
This is from an actual application... and is the way coaches can get students with sub-standard grades into the college
I'm not saying that is right, but that is what I experienced.