if that was stated to my son, by a coach who wanted "early commitment" whether by ED or NLI, my advice would be - IF the fit is right andquote:"we think you can make an immediate impact as a freshman"
YOU believe YOU can make an immediate impact - say YES,
that's an opportunity staring you in the face
YOU do NOT believe you can make an immediate impact - say YES,
that's an opportunity staring you in the face given by someone who believes in you
the resulting impact you make is up to you
jmo
.