Originally Posted by Skylark:
I know it sounds cheesy but here goes- I score it all players safe on fielders choice with an error assigned to team and not player if it is clearly obvious it was an umpire miscall.
With all due respect, I've never scored an error to a "team". I've always given it to a player. Like a put out for the catcher when the batter steps on a fair ball, it isn't necessarily fair, they didn't earn it, but somebody has to either get it or pay the penalty.
In this vein, I don't keep defensive stats in HS. Way too small a sample size and the coaches can see good / bad on their own.