Agree, all-around good catchers are very tough to come by. It is such a difficult position because there are so many things to know and do well throughout a game. I too think that pitching and hitting are the major factors of the game, and a catcher is half of the "pitching" team, as well as an infielder, and his pitchers must have confidence in him behind the plate. The pitching-catching connection is huge. We all know that great catchers are able to obtain many more strikes than a pitcher really throws. As for hitting, of course, he should probably be able to hit the ball too, and perhaps even steal a base or two when he gets on. I believe it is the most difficult position to play well all-around, and the least recognized. I am sure that others have their own perspectives on other positions.