It always baffles me with that what seems to be a pretty straight forward "hypothetical situation", is described, parameters for said situation are given/described, and a response requested for a BASEBALL ONLY decision, why everyone has to turn it in to a lot of other things but that? Is it really that hard? I can understand that for some there are a "lot of other factors" in a decision, but this was a pretty simple question based on a set of rules listed by the OP. Just sayin......