Our "annointed" catchers for the past couple of classes have all chosen the truck, girl, and job over baseball. We've been fortunate to find a hard working kid that had skills fill the spot without ever missing a beat. Who knows how much a kid is going to grow, mature, or maintain their desire when the given age is 12? Heck no, don't give up on your child's position. My child is the "annointed" one in our community. However, she has stiff competition coming along. She knows that. It only makes her better. I think knowing a player is out there trying to take your position is an essential in player development. JMHO!