Skip to main content

Reply to "JUCO Coaches"

I'm just a humble D3 parent, where things seem more purely what the NCAA's ideal is:  you are a student who plays baseball.  You are doing two things at once:  practicing/playing baseball, and taking classes.  It's not easy.  Some players focus more on baseball, some on classes, it shows in the performance of each.  You are playing because you love it, not because you are getting money.

In theory this is how it is supposed to be at all levels, the difference being that you are playing for scholarship money so you can be a student and play baseball.  Everyone knows that is not the case, but it's the ideal.  Changing the NIL rule at the same time as shortening the draft and changing the transfer rule - was it coincidence, due to covid?  Must have been, because the NIL rule and covid/transfer is for all sports, the draft just impacted baseball.  Clearly, though, the convergence of those 3 things gave MLB the idea that they can now rely on college baseball to be a minor league.

Watching summer league baseball makes me realize the huge difference between playing baseball while taking classes, and playing baseball when all you have to do is focus on baseball.  Even MLB is not going to get the NCAA to do away with the requirement that student-athletes be students too, regardless of how much of a joke some of the "classes" must be.

The sit-out rule was to discourage transfers, and to encourage players to actually get their degrees.  It's not like business and changing jobs.  If you change jobs voluntarily, you presumably don't go backward the way you do if you transfer schools.

So, indentured servitude - yes, in the money sports it is.  Baseball is not money-making at the vast majority of schools.  That's why the NIL is corrupt.  If they had made it so that popular players could be in advertisements or selling autographs or jerseys, or making money from social media, that would be fine.  Setting it up so rich alumni can "pay" them is just rotten.  Maybe it gets away from the taint of everyone making money except the athletes, but that doesn't make it better.

Last edited by anotherparent
×
×
×
×