I saw one guy had Reynolds as #2 in the SFG farm system, though I think most had him more like 5 or 6. #2 round draft choice. Vandy player. Obviously a high average hitter but good size and seems to be hitting with more power as he's moved through MILB. Could be a good to very good MLB player. You never know. And Crick as a former first rounder hasn't quite lived up to potential so far, but he's got a live arm and could also be very good down the road.
As a Giants fan I like the deal, but I think it's very possible that 2-3 years from now Pirate fans will be much happier with this trade than Giants fans.