Thanks, Pirate Fan. Sure helps going into this process getting a lot of different perspectives.
Academic--they have a couple of majors my son is interested in--the GOLF major (not sure that will work with playing baseball, though), and their Strength and Conditioning Major (with a minor in coaching).
Small School--I think he would actually thrive on a smaller campus. Would be a good fit.
Recruiting--I have a better understanding of that process after several responded to my "Over Recruiting at D-III" thread on the recruiting board. Wherever he goes at that level, it's a **** shoot for both parties. I (and he) have to have the confidence he can get the job done.