Skip to main content

Reply to "National Anthem....the other side of the coin!"

2020dad posted:

Root history teacher to history teacher...  You too are skewing the facts to support your argument. 'White people' didn't own EVERYTHING...  A very small handful of white people owned everything - and yes it does matter. The understanding of this is critical to this entire debate. Root being the historian you are I am sure you are well aware of the conditions in the company towns of the industrial revolution. And the tenement buildings no doubt many of our ancestors lived in. And what they had to do to get their families out of that poverty and downright dangerous life threatening environment. Now I am not in for the 'who had it better' argument. I simply am not willing to go there although all we historians have at one time or another examined that topic. Yes we need to be aware of these things but at the same time in order to move forward we really do have to put the past in the past. That does NOT automatically minimize the significance of history but it does enhance our chances for greatness in the future. And root while I agree with you that the original intent of the old time democrats was to help I believe the modern Democratic Party has stumbled on the realization that they can feed the minority community just enough to keep them at sustenance level and keep their votes rolling in. It is systematic oppression.  And since this thread is so far off the charts politically and religiously I will get my two cents in...  You imply that social acceptance of a given era does not forgive immorality. Just as we gape in horror at the thought of the Romans discarding babies in the woods so to will we someday look on the horrors of our modern day equivalent to that practice. Hope you liberals feel the same shame over that some day. And now here comes the double standard you watch. After all that has been said on this thread mine will be the one to catch the wrath of the censors. But in fact it is open and honest communication like this that will HELP not hurt our chances. I used to teach my students that race relations are like a boiling pot with the lid on.  We keep everything suppressed and some day the lid will blow.  That someday is sadly getting closer. We need open communication even if it initially causes anger. We must negotiate and listen and even scream and yell at each other sometimes if necessary to come out a stronger nation. Or we can have another person come in here and tell us to sweep it back under the rug and get back to baseball. 

P.S. Root I am sure you are also well aware of the atrocities against the settlers by the hands of select tribes as well right?  And because I know we both want to be fair historians I will reach out the olive branch on this one and say there is no clear pattern that suggests either side 'started it' or is completely innocent. Now move to the center just a tad and come with me on that statement at least. 

Also don't forget that moving minimum wage to a level that would make it economically equivalent to minimum wage in 1966 isn't feeding " the minority community just enough to keep them at sustenance level and keep their votes rolling in." It's trying to better their lives. Opposing an increase to those making far below what it takes to sustain life might be, though. This used to be a country where no matter what you did for a living, if you worked hard for 40 hours a week, you could keep yourself and your family fed and sheltered. It's not that anymore. By the way, who broke up those company towns? Unions.

×
×
×
×