Jim, I think you're putting too much importance on PG rankings, All Tournament Teams, etc. Yes, I have no doubt that college coaches (and MLB scouts) look at those things, and it influences who they take a closer look at, but I just don't believe that it influences the final decision. They all want to see the guy play, talk to his coaches, and make their own evaluation. They aren't lazy, at least not the ones I've met. Don't forget, most of these guys have to win games to keep their jobs.
Your All Tournament example sounds personal, so you probably know the details, but I know of many cases where kids are listed on a tournament roster but did not actually attend.
I agree with this 100% - PG has it's place in the recruiting process, but in the end coaches recruit kids they put their eyes on and to determine whether they fit their needs. PG probably does the best in the business in organizing places where coaches can see players and vice versa. I doubt many players have been recruited because they scored a X.X by PG evaluators.