2019CubDad.....I get the issues you're describing, and some of the blame obviously goes to the kid...especially if he had the attitude issues as bad as you make it sound....BUT....where was the coach? Chairs and fists in the locker room? C'mon, the coach has to shut that down IMMEDIATELY!! If it happens once, fine....if it continues, it's on him. Either he gets the upperclassmen on board if he feels they are to blame....if they won't, then it's on them. If he feels it's the freshman, make a change...one way or the other he needs to handle it. If he can't, then he has no business coaching HS kids. A team with that kind of talent going 2-10 is crazy. I obviously don't know the guy....but I guess I would wonder if was a "coach" or was he a "guy in a uniform" that got handed a bunch of top level travel kids every year and just had to throw them on the field to win games?