The fact that Mitchell Shiflett from Cosby might be getting as much interest from pro scouts as any player in recent memory might be a factor in the end - especially if he has the huge season he's capable of at the plate.
Ryan Morrison is an option if he swings the stick well because he could easily win 10+ games this season.
My dark horse for POY is Connor Kaufman from LC Bird. He's as good a pitcher as anyone in the district and if he gets regular AB's this spring (as he should) he has the capability to hit 8-10 bombs on a team that might surprise people if they find a second arm.