Skip to main content

Reply to "Success and failure"

Hope that you're right about the old timers committee but I think it's a crapshoot at that point.

 

Agree Morris is near the line for HOF, but don't agree that he would redraw any boundaries. For instance, the group of contemporaries you originally threw out don't qualify in my mind.  And the most suspect election in recent memory would still be Blyleven.

 

You're probably right about Whittaker, I'm sure it's every man for himself.  I don't think Whittaker or Trammel warrant the Hall.

×
×
×
×