Bkekcs,
You are correct, NFHS rules forbid the use of a the traditional mask and skull cap.....Its a one piece helmet with dual ear protection only.
Regardless of mask type, as fungo can readily endorse, the effects of fouls to the catcher (and umpires) can result in serious injury.
My prayers are for a speedy recovery for Josh!!
There is a great deal of discussion regarding the impact qualities of both masks going on in umpire circles right now. I expect someone to come up with the appropriate data to support both types very soon....(everyone has their own experts....).
For 20 years Ive worn the traditional mask...before that as a catcher I wore the traditional mask and skull cap....I like the proectetion of the HSM, but not the look or the ease of removal for umpire duties...
a direct hard foul to the mask regardless of protection, is a reason to check your catcher...