coach
I saw Mantle, Mays and Snider back in the 50's and 60's---Mantle was an unreal player
Manny is a much better fielder than people give him credit for mainly because he seems to not care at times
I agree with you that Mantle is/was the better player but the offensive numbers tip the scales to Manny as a hitter
Personally I take Mays over both of them as both a player and hitter