I have seen this first hand. A catcher on my son’s high school team would sometimes throw the ball to center field. I’m not talking just a high throw; he would actually launch it to the centerfielder. Even he didn’t have a clue why he would do this. The coach had to move him to first base. He also pitched some with no throwing problem. The coach also told me of a college catcher that would sometimes throw to first base when a runner was stealing second. He told me his mind was thinking 2nd but he would throw to 1b.
Fungo
Never argue with an idiot. They drag you down to their level, then beat you with experience.