I think it depends on 1) who you face and 2) the level of hitter in question.
1) Who you face - Not all pitchers at PG are top tier pitchers. I've seen many who I am convinced couldn't make a HS varsity team. I have also seen a team or two with rotations better than most colleges. What is "easier" to hit?
2) The level of hitter - Is the hitter disciplined to not chase pitches from a slop pitcher? Does he have elite level batspeed? Is he capable of handling quality secondary stuff? All of these play into your answer.