I will refrain from ascribing guilt/innocence or even from commenting on what people do in the bedroom (no matter how much I don't get it) because there is just so much we don't know about both sides of this story.
But, that aside, Bauer is done. He will never command the money he did nor will he every be as popular as he once was. (Even if it's proven she was on board). My son was a huge Bauer fan. He admired his passion and work ethic and slightly nerdy analytical approach to pitching. Now he's out. He said "worst case, he's a rapist. Best case, he's a freak. Either way I'm out" unsubscribed from his social media and dropped him from his fantasy baseball team. I suspect he isn't the only one.
You're only worth big money to the MLB if you have a fanbase/following. Think about how much flack Trout gets just because he doesn't want to do non-baseball stuff in the public eye...