Had to make a couple changes, subbed Posey for Rizzo so the hitters wouldn't have 2 1B, used a collection of various randoms as the "average" players, and where possible duplicated the randoms for both teams. So, both teams had the same 7 relievers, the same LF (Brett Gardner), the same SS (Asdrubal Cabrera), etc. "Hitter" team rotation was Fiers, Hammel, Colon, Koehler, and Happ. All based on 2015 numbers, run through a 162 game season with DMB.
Hitters went 101-61 the first season I simmed. Hitters best SP performance was probably Colon's 17-5, 3.02. Glen Perkins went 2-3, 3.30 with 26 saves as the closer. Hitters best offensive performance was Harper's 310/417/632 with 48 HR, 136 R, 98 RBI.
Pitchers best SP performance was Kershaw's 8-14, 3.99. Perkins went 5-3, 3.04 with 17 saves for them. Best hitting performance was probably Adrian Gonzalez' 238/298/400 with 24 HR, 57 R, 88 RBI.
Results were much the same on additional runs. Stacking offensive studs, apparently, is more valuable to generating runs than having a stud SP is to preventing them.