From what I've seen the Regional differences are huge in Baseball. Some of these Northeast D1's are really only D1 because they are D1 in other sports. Not to rip on a program, but Villanova, for example, does not appear to put forth a lot of effort in attempting to field a strong program. I don't believe they fully fund their scholarship allotment. When I watched them a year ago, I felt as if they were on par with the California D3 teams from the SCIAC.
Villanova wouldn't destroy them at steady diet of the top local D3's but they would win the vast majority and if you stacked up the games Nova would dominate at the bottom of the rotations. Villanova isn't good, the top local D3's are.
There is a difference and I am a big fan of the local D3 circuit.
I have seen no evidence from national play that the California D3's are any better then the midatlanitc / northeast ones. There are national caliber teams, within the driving distance for nonleague games in all directions of Philly.
AD2018 posted:From what I've seen the Regional differences are huge in Baseball. Some of these Northeast D1's are really only D1 because they are D1 in other sports. Not to rip on a program, but Villanova, for example, does not appear to put forth a lot of effort in attempting to field a strong program. I don't believe they fully fund their scholarship allotment. When I watched them a year ago, I felt as if they were on par with the California D3 teams from the SCIAC.
Villanova isn’t that bad. But they’re not good. Now that my son is turning 26 and I moved I’m less tuned in. But they used to have two or three players drafted each year. But they were a Big East bottom feeder when the Big East was a P6.
Their field is in a town park ten miles from campus. There aren’t any concession stands or bathrooms. I heard they only fund six scholarships.
Basketball and track are the big sports along with FCS football.
"Yes this is division 1 baseball"
I'm sure it gets better than this for both teams, but man this is ugly from start to finish. This is one of the very conferences RJM was referring to. I'm fairly confident a good D3 can take some D1s out now.
I was just giving a talk at Bradley University ... which is a very small D1 school with not a huge amount of money to spend on scholarships.
One of my hosts is a huge college sports fan, as am I so we started talking the advantages and disadvantages of being a small, underfunded bottom feeding D1 vs being a competitive D3.
He said he'd been urging the powers that be to switch to D3 in sports for years, but to no avail. (he's been on various committees at the school that have input into such matters.)
The powers that be HOPE that somehow basketball (they don't do football) will be a source of TV revenue and national interest, if they can just manage to dominate their league ... which includes last year's Cinderella team Loyola. The basketball team did make the tournament, but went one and done.
My hosts thinks it's a bad bet for the school, overall. Especially since they suffer from declining enrollments, have a small endowments, and are heavily tuition dependent.
He thinks they would be better off using D3 sports to attract more paying customers and should aim to be a highly competitive D3 program at which students will "pay to play."
I wonder how many bottom feeder D1 programs face this kind of choice and whether some of them will eventually opt for the D3 route .... mainly to keep those tuition dollars flowing.
PABaseball posted:"Yes this is division 1 baseball"
I'm sure it gets better than this for both teams, but man this is ugly from start to finish. This is one of the very conferences RJM was referring to. I'm fairly confident a good D3 can take some D1s out now.
It’s not the one I was referring to specifically. It’s the other one. That’s Coppin State’s field. Look at the field. I’ll bet plenty of sons of posters played on nicer high school fields.
But, I’ll give the Coppin State coach credit. He came on board when they went 0-50 with a 16+ era and a .160 team batting average. A couple of years later they only had fourteen players. Then they could only play thirty-something games as they had trouble getting out of conference games. Regardless of the level of play they have a full roster and a winning record this season.
SluggerDad posted:I was just giving a talk at Bradley University ... which is a very small D1 school with not a huge amount of money to spend on scholarships.
One of my hosts is a huge college sports fan, as am I so we started talking the advantages and disadvantages of being a small, underfunded bottom feeding D1 vs being a competitive D3.
He said he'd been urging the powers that be to switch to D3 in sports for years, but to no avail. (he's been on various committees at the school that have input into such matters.)
The powers that be HOPE that somehow basketball (they don't do football) will be a source of TV revenue and national interest, if they can just manage to dominate their league ... which includes last year's Cinderella team Loyola. The basketball team did make the tournament, but went one and done.
My hosts thinks it's a bad bet for the school, overall. Especially since they suffer from declining enrollments, have a small endowments, and are heavily tuition dependent.
He thinks they would be better off using D3 sports to attract more paying customers and should aim to be a highly competitive D3 program at which students will "pay to play."
I wonder how many bottom feeder D1 programs face this kind of choice and whether some of them will eventually opt for the D3 route .... mainly to keep those tuition dollars flowing.
Just like players sometimes making a bad decision choosing a D1 over a D3 for perceived prestige reasons I think college athletic departments sometimes make the same mistake.
Speaking of prestigious progams did the Sprint Center have to be deloused after Calipari and Pearl coached against each other today? That’s a lot of slime on the sidelines at the same time.
RJM posted:Speaking of prestigious progams did the Sprint Center have to be deloused after Calipari and Pearl coached against each other today? That’s a lot of slime on the sidelines at the same time.
To offset the high Calipari & Pearl skeeve factor, the Sprint Center staff was seen handing out complimentary Purell showers for its patrons.
I heard there was some consideration to changing the venue to the Roach Motel.
RJM posted:PABaseball posted:"Yes this is division 1 baseball"
I'm sure it gets better than this for both teams, but man this is ugly from start to finish. This is one of the very conferences RJM was referring to. I'm fairly confident a good D3 can take some D1s out now.
It’s not the one I was referring to specifically. It’s the other one. That’s Coppin State’s field. Look at the field. I’ll plenty of sons of posters played on nicer high school fields.
But, I’ll give the Coppin State coach credit. He came on board when they went 0-50 with a 16+ era and a 160 team batting average. A couple of years later they only had fourteen players. Then they could only play thirty-something games as they had trouble getting out of conference games. Regardless of the level of play they have a full roster and a winning record this season.
Yes, credit to them. I can't imagine recruiting being too easy down there, but good to see them winning some games. Very good chance they're a tournament team this year.
Buckeye 2015 posted:A current junior throwing 92 with no offers? Can at he at least throw it where the catcher can catch it 2 out of 5 times?
Yes sir. Actually a dominant pitcher. Here's the issue... he's 5'11" - maybe.
PABaseball posted:"Yes this is division 1 baseball"
I'm sure it gets better than this for both teams, but man this is ugly from start to finish. This is one of the very conferences RJM was referring to. I'm fairly confident a good D3 can take some D1s out now.
I have never seen any D1 baseball that looks like that!
adbono posted:PABaseball posted:"Yes this is division 1 baseball"
I'm sure it gets better than this for both teams, but man this is ugly from start to finish. This is one of the very conferences RJM was referring to. I'm fairly confident a good D3 can take some D1s out now.
I have never seen any D1 baseball that looks like that!
You don’t remember seeing D1 play like that. I remember MLB play like that because it was my team. A couple of years ago I watched the Red Sox clear the bases with three errant throws on one play. The ball banged off both the right field and left field walls.,
PABaseball posted:"Yes this is division 1 baseball"
I'm sure it gets better than this for both teams, but man this is ugly from start to finish. This is one of the very conferences RJM was referring to. I'm fairly confident a good D3 can take some D1s out now.
This is a MEAC conference game, and those are two of the teams I referred to earlier. It's a rough clip, and I don't think it's representative of the conference in general. However, like I said earlier, MEAC teams would not be out of place in many D3 conferences.
2020dad posted:Buckeye 2015 posted:A current junior throwing 92 with no offers? Can at he at least throw it where the catcher can catch it 2 out of 5 times?
Yes sir. Actually a dominant pitcher. Here's the issue... he's 5'11" - maybe.
I've been to 20 or so of my son's games so far this year....I think I've only seen 3 guys over 90...and one of them is on our team. Hard to believe, that even at 5'11 that someone hasn't offered him. My son was 88-89 when he committed the summer after his junior year. He was 5'9 or 5'10 and maybe 150 lbs at the time.
Buckeye 2015 posted:2020dad posted:Buckeye 2015 posted:A current junior throwing 92 with no offers? Can at he at least throw it where the catcher can catch it 2 out of 5 times?
Yes sir. Actually a dominant pitcher. Here's the issue... he's 5'11" - maybe.
I've been to 20 or so of my son's games so far this year....I think I've only seen 3 guys over 90...and one of them is on our team. Hard to believe, that even at 5'11 that someone hasn't offered him. My son was 88-89 when he committed the summer after his junior year. He was 5'9 or 5'10 and maybe 150 lbs at the time.
And he's a great student! The 92 is showcase verified. No saying when weather warms he may not go 93 or 94. It's a stone cold mystery to me. But I am sure this summer the offers will come.
RJM posted:adbono posted:PABaseball posted:"Yes this is division 1 baseball"
I'm sure it gets better than this for both teams, but man this is ugly from start to finish. This is one of the very conferences RJM was referring to. I'm fairly confident a good D3 can take some D1s out now.
I have never seen any D1 baseball that looks like that!
You don’t remember seeing D1 play like that. I remember MLB play like that because it was my team. A couple of years ago I watched the Red Sox clear the bases with three errant throws on one play. The ball banged off both the right field and left field walls.,
Errant throws happen at all levels of baseball. I was referring to the general lack of athleticism, idiotic base running, terrible execution of a rundown, and the catcher tripping the baserunner. To see all that in such a short clip is what prompted my comment.
adbono posted:Errant throws happen at all levels of baseball. I was referring to the general lack of athleticism, idiotic base running, terrible execution of a rundown, and the catcher tripping the baserunner. To see all that in such a short clip is what prompted my comment.
You mean the baserunner intentionally running into the catcher and flopping right?
For the record I started this thread about a Metro Atlantic. (MAAC) team. In Boyd’s they’re right at the bottom with the MEAC. They’re the same conversation.
Buckeye 2015 posted:adbono posted:Errant throws happen at all levels of baseball. I was referring to the general lack of athleticism, idiotic base running, terrible execution of a rundown, and the catcher tripping the baserunner. To see all that in such a short clip is what prompted my comment.
You mean the baserunner intentionally running into the catcher and flopping right?
That too
Buckeye 2015 posted:2020dad posted:Buckeye 2015 posted:A current junior throwing 92 with no offers? Can at he at least throw it where the catcher can catch it 2 out of 5 times?
Yes sir. Actually a dominant pitcher. Here's the issue... he's 5'11" - maybe.
I've been to 20 or so of my son's games so far this year....I think I've only seen 3 guys over 90...and one of them is on our team. Hard to believe, that even at 5'11 that someone hasn't offered him. My son was 88-89 when he committed the summer after his junior year. He was 5'9 or 5'10 and maybe 150 lbs at the time.
There's a good chance the schools that have seen him think there's no way he'll end up at their level. And the schools at his level haven't seen him yet.
I was talking to a coach at a summer game and asked what he thought of our pitcher. He said he looks great, but he's too good for them. I thought the same. The kid was throwing 91, but never got in front of the right schools and when he did they already had their classes set. He's going to a D3 for the academics, I'm sure he'll have no problem walking on there.
MidAtlanticDad posted:PABaseball posted:"Yes this is division 1 baseball"
I'm sure it gets better than this for both teams, but man this is ugly from start to finish. This is one of the very conferences RJM was referring to. I'm fairly confident a good D3 can take some D1s out now.
This is a MEAC conference game, and those are two of the teams I referred to earlier. It's a rough clip, and I don't think it's representative of the conference in general. However, like I said earlier, MEAC teams would not be out of place in many D3 conferences.
Those were my thoughts as well. Just using it to prove that not every D1 has guys throwing 90+ and slick fielders. I know it is only one clip and I don't know the situation, but the lack of athleticism did surprise me.
Without digging at the guys too hard, if you showed me this clip and told me it was a HS team, I wouldn't think twice bout it. But I've also seen the Marlins play like this in July so everybody has their day.
RJM posted:For the record I started this thread about a Metro Atlantic. (MAAC) team. In Boyd’s they’re right at the bottom with the MEAC. They’re the same conversation.
A MAAC team just whipped #22 UCONN
CTbballDad posted:RJM posted:For the record I started this thread about a Metro Atlantic. (MAAC) team. In Boyd’s they’re right at the bottom with the MEAC. They’re the same conversation.
A MAAC team just whipped #22 UCONN
UCONN probably over-rated a bit at #22
It’s tiresome when people in TX, FL and CA call every team not from their conference overrated. UConn is off to a good start. They’ve beaten some good teams. Starting off the season beating Louisville two of three draws positive attention. They’re 3-2 against ranked teams.
Last year they were 37-22. They beat ranked #13 Coastal to get to their regional final against Washington. They were one game from a Super Series.
Fairfield is in third place in their low rated conference. They probably caught UConn over confident and going through the motions. Fairfield jumped to a quick 7-2 lead. It puts pressure on the team that shouldn’t lose. I’ll bet UConn feels so humiliated they beat Fairfield by ten runs next year to make a point.
RJM posted:It’s tiresome when people in TX, FL and CA call every team not from their conference overrated. UConn is off to a good start. They’ve beaten some good teams. Starting off the season beating Louisville two of three draws positive attention. They’re 3-2 against ranked teams.
Last year they were 37-22. They beat ranked #13 Coastal to get to their regional final against Washington. They were one game from a Super Series.
Fairfield is in third place in their low rated conference. They probably caught UConn over confident and going through the motions. Fairfield jumped to a quick 7-2 lead. It puts pressure on the team that shouldn’t lose. I’ll bet UConn feels so humiliated they beat Fairfield by ten runs next year to make a point.
It may be tiresome but it’s true. Way better baseball is played in the states you mentioned by name than anywhere in the Northeast. There is an occasional outlier and east coast media loves to jump on that bandwagon. UCONN has a few good wins but also has some not so good losses. Their schedule is better than most and they are obviously pretty good. What I said was that they were probably a bit over-rated at #22 and I stand by that. I’m pretty sure there are 25 teams that are better than UCONN. Just my opinion.
BC just knocked FSU out of the top 25 after taking 2/3 and also has wins over Louisville and Clemson. BC and UCONN are the only power conference teams in NE, and when given a chance they more than hold there own. It’s more a matter of quantity, not quality, IMO.
It may be tiresome but it’s true. Way better baseball is played in the states you mentioned by name than anywhere in the Northeast. There is an occasional outlier and east coast media loves to jump on that bandwagon. UCONN has a few good wins but also has some not so good losses. Their schedule is better than most and they are obviously pretty good. What I said was that they were probably a bit over-rated at #22 and I stand by that. I’m pretty sure there are 25 teams that are better than UCONN. Just my opinion.
While that may be true in general, but at least in D3, the Wisconsin schools consistently field top 25 teams - year in and year out. UWW a few years ago was one of the most physically impressive teams I saw in 4 years of watching championship D3 ball. It's just baseball if you try to make a "generalization" as it will prove you wrong....which is the beauty of the game.
adbono posted:RJM posted:It’s tiresome when people in TX, FL and CA call every team not from their conference overrated. UConn is off to a good start. They’ve beaten some good teams. Starting off the season beating Louisville two of three draws positive attention. They’re 3-2 against ranked teams.
Last year they were 37-22. They beat ranked #13 Coastal to get to their regional final against Washington. They were one game from a Super Series.
Fairfield is in third place in their low rated conference. They probably caught UConn over confident and going through the motions. Fairfield jumped to a quick 7-2 lead. It puts pressure on the team that shouldn’t lose. I’ll bet UConn feels so humiliated they beat Fairfield by ten runs next year to make a point.
It may be tiresome but it’s true. Way better baseball is played in the states you mentioned by name than anywhere in the Northeast. There is an occasional outlier and east coast media loves to jump on that bandwagon. UCONN has a few good wins but also has some not so good losses. Their schedule is better than most and they are obviously pretty good. What I said was that they were probably a bit over-rated at #22 and I stand by that. I’m pretty sure there are 25 teams that are better than UCONN. Just my opinion.
No one is arguing the ball is better than in other areas. But the condescension and dismissiveness is f’ing obnoxious.
A lot of northeast players head for the ACC. George Springer must suck. He grew up in CT and played for UConn along with Red Sox closer Matt Barnes. The year Vanderbilt won the CWS their #1, #2, closer and cleanup hitter were all from Massachusetts.
The experts say UConn is in the top 25. Your view is just a two bit opinion.
RJM posted:adbono posted:RJM posted:It’s tiresome when people in TX, FL and CA call every team not from their conference overrated. UConn is off to a good start. They’ve beaten some good teams. Starting off the season beating Louisville two of three draws positive attention. They’re 3-2 against ranked teams.
Last year they were 37-22. They beat ranked #13 Coastal to get to their regional final against Washington. They were one game from a Super Series.
Fairfield is in third place in their low rated conference. They probably caught UConn over confident and going through the motions. Fairfield jumped to a quick 7-2 lead. It puts pressure on the team that shouldn’t lose. I’ll bet UConn feels so humiliated they beat Fairfield by ten runs next year to make a point.
It may be tiresome but it’s true. Way better baseball is played in the states you mentioned by name than anywhere in the Northeast. There is an occasional outlier and east coast media loves to jump on that bandwagon. UCONN has a few good wins but also has some not so good losses. Their schedule is better than most and they are obviously pretty good. What I said was that they were probably a bit over-rated at #22 and I stand by that. I’m pretty sure there are 25 teams that are better than UCONN. Just my opinion.
No one is arguing the ball is better than in other areas. But the condescension and dismissiveness is f’ing obnoxious.
I guess my kids sucked because they came from the northeast even though they played for P6’s (Big East was a P6 before imploding). George Springer must suck. He grew up in CT and played for UConn along with Red Sox closer Matt Barnes. The year Vanderbilt won the CWS their #1, #2, closer and cleanup hitter were all from Massachusetts.
The experts say UConn is in the top 25. Your view is just a two bit opinion.
Again, what I said was UCONN is probably over-rated A BIT at #22.
Over-react much ???
CTbballDad posted:BC just knocked FSU out of the top 25 after taking 2/3 and also has wins over Louisville and Clemson. BC and UCONN are the only power conference teams in NE, and when given a chance they more than hold there own. It’s more a matter of quantity, not quality, IMO.
BC and UConn will always lose the better northeast players to the ACC. They will always lose the best to Vanderbilt. Corbin is from NH. He has a lot of eyes in the northeast.
adbono posted:RJM posted:adbono posted:RJM posted:It’s tiresome when people in TX, FL and CA call every team not from their conference overrated. UConn is off to a good start. They’ve beaten some good teams. Starting off the season beating Louisville two of three draws positive attention. They’re 3-2 against ranked teams.
Last year they were 37-22. They beat ranked #13 Coastal to get to their regional final against Washington. They were one game from a Super Series.
Fairfield is in third place in their low rated conference. They probably caught UConn over confident and going through the motions. Fairfield jumped to a quick 7-2 lead. It puts pressure on the team that shouldn’t lose. I’ll bet UConn feels so humiliated they beat Fairfield by ten runs next year to make a point.
It may be tiresome but it’s true. Way better baseball is played in the states you mentioned by name than anywhere in the Northeast. There is an occasional outlier and east coast media loves to jump on that bandwagon. UCONN has a few good wins but also has some not so good losses. Their schedule is better than most and they are obviously pretty good. What I said was that they were probably a bit over-rated at #22 and I stand by that. I’m pretty sure there are 25 teams that are better than UCONN. Just my opinion.
No one is arguing the ball is better than in other areas. But the condescension and dismissiveness is f’ing obnoxious.
I guess my kids sucked because they came from the northeast even though they played for P6’s (Big East was a P6 before imploding). George Springer must suck. He grew up in CT and played for UConn along with Red Sox closer Matt Barnes. The year Vanderbilt won the CWS their #1, #2, closer and cleanup hitter were all from Massachusetts.
The experts say UConn is in the top 25. Your view is just a two bit opinion.
Again, what I said was UCONN is probably over-rated A BIT at #22.
Over-react much ???
I’m tired of the condescension and dismissiveness some people on this board have for quality ball players from other areas of the country.
There’s sometimes an attitude on this board if from TX, CA and FL your kid’s farts don’t smell. If you’re from certain areas of the country your kid is overrated and just not that good.
Iowa beat D2 Clarke University tonight by a score of just 3-2
RJM posted:adbono posted:RJM posted:adbono posted:RJM posted:It’s tiresome when people in TX, FL and CA call every team not from their conference overrated. UConn is off to a good start. They’ve beaten some good teams. Starting off the season beating Louisville two of three draws positive attention. They’re 3-2 against ranked teams.
Last year they were 37-22. They beat ranked #13 Coastal to get to their regional final against Washington. They were one game from a Super Series.
Fairfield is in third place in their low rated conference. They probably caught UConn over confident and going through the motions. Fairfield jumped to a quick 7-2 lead. It puts pressure on the team that shouldn’t lose. I’ll bet UConn feels so humiliated they beat Fairfield by ten runs next year to make a point.
It may be tiresome but it’s true. Way better baseball is played in the states you mentioned by name than anywhere in the Northeast. There is an occasional outlier and east coast media loves to jump on that bandwagon. UCONN has a few good wins but also has some not so good losses. Their schedule is better than most and they are obviously pretty good. What I said was that they were probably a bit over-rated at #22 and I stand by that. I’m pretty sure there are 25 teams that are better than UCONN. Just my opinion.
No one is arguing the ball is better than in other areas. But the condescension and dismissiveness is f’ing obnoxious.
I guess my kids sucked because they came from the northeast even though they played for P6’s (Big East was a P6 before imploding). George Springer must suck. He grew up in CT and played for UConn along with Red Sox closer Matt Barnes. The year Vanderbilt won the CWS their #1, #2, closer and cleanup hitter were all from Massachusetts.
The experts say UConn is in the top 25. Your view is just a two bit opinion.
Again, what I said was UCONN is probably over-rated A BIT at #22.
Over-react much ???
I’m tired of the condescension and dismissiveness some people on this board have for quality ball players from other areas of the country.
There’s sometimes an attitude on this board if from TX, CA and FL your kid’s farts don’t smell. If you’re from certain areas of the country your kid is overrated and just not that good.
That sounds like a personal problem to me.
RJM posted:No. My kids are done playing. They now have great educations and great jobs. Just tired of sh*tty, condescensing, dismissive attitudes of posters from certain parts of the country.
That sounds like the pot calling the kettle black.
adbono posted:RJM posted:No. My kids are done playing. They now have great educations and great jobs. Just tired of sh*tty, condescensing, dismissive attitudes of posters from certain parts of the country.
That sounds like the pot calling the kettle black.
For some reason you seem to be trying to antagonize me. I wasn’t trying to make it personal. You seem to be working at it. I’m out.
RJM posted:adbono posted:RJM posted:No. My kids are done playing. They now have great educations and great jobs. Just tired of sh*tty, condescensing, dismissive attitudes of posters from certain parts of the country.
That sounds like the pot calling the kettle black.
For some reason you seem to be trying to antagonize me. I wasn’t trying to make it personal. You seem to be working at it. I’m out.
You were absolutely making it personal. But I agree that there is no need to continue.