Skip to main content

2015 catcher son wants to switch to the pro-style cage + cap for summer ball.  He says that the cage + cap are lighter and cooler.  I think he mostly likes the look.  I once found some information from All-Star that the full facemask provides 7 times more protection from a concussion than the traditional facemask.  Of course my son says he's never heard of a catcher getting a concussion from a foul tip anyway.

 

Anyone have any experience and/or opinions?

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Originally Posted by MidAtlanticDad:

  Of course my son says he's never heard of a catcher getting a concussion from a foul tip anyway.

 

Anyone have any experience and/or opinions?

I was actually just telling play_baseball this earlier today.. I suffered two in high school from foul tips.

 

Maybe your son has heard of a guy by the name of Mike Matheny? Had his career ended from post-concussion syndrome from foul tips. Or maybe Kerwin Danley who is an MLB umpire? The Boston Red Sox catcher who has suffered two this year?

My kid likes the skull cap as well, as pulling the hockey mask off hurriedly -- as catchers do -- caused injuries to his ears.  He wears it any time it is legal.  However, the kid needs to be a very experienced catcher because some less experienced catchers will turn their head when ball hits the ground, which is disastrous with a skull cap  As for concussions from bats, I cannot opine on that.

Originally Posted by El Conquistador:
I'm a long time lurker, this is my first post here. See the link for what I felt was some good info on the subject. Hope you don't have to cut and paste.
http://community.hsbaseballweb...s-maskskull-cap?nc=1

 

Thank you EL.  I should have found that myself.  That discussion pretty much covers everything.  Bottom line, I think he will always be at risk with either headgear style.  Both appear to offer pretty good protection, and though the hockey style does have advantages, I won't be overly concerned if he ever chooses the traditional style.

 

Originally Posted by Aleebaba:

My kid likes the skull cap as well, as pulling the hockey mask off hurriedly -- as catchers do -- caused injuries to his ears. 


Ask him why he is pulling his mask off in the first place... There really isn't any need to take the hockey-style mask off. In fact, the only time I would even consider doing so would be a Popfly and I'm not sure I'd do that. When I caught, the mask didn't come off.

Originally Posted by Bulldog 19:
Originally Posted by Aleebaba:

My kid likes the skull cap as well, as pulling the hockey mask off hurriedly -- as catchers do -- caused injuries to his ears. 


Ask him why he is pulling his mask off in the first place... There really isn't any need to take the hockey-style mask off. In fact, the only time I would even consider doing so would be a Popfly and I'm not sure I'd do that. When I caught, the mask didn't come off.

That's how he was taught and now it is ingrained. 

I know that this is an old topic but I've just joined and wanted to throw my 2 cents in. The hockey style helmet is designed so it is to never leave the head during play. That is where you get the benefits of that style of helmet. When I played (1999 grad) the cost, lack of availability of the hockey style helmet, and having a large melon prevented me from using it.

As for those having worries about the lack of ear protection on the traditional style masks. Teaching proper blocking techniques is the most important thing to do. Chin down and follow the ball to your chest. The head turn does more that expose the side of the head it exposes the throat area, which is even more dangerous.  I had a good friend of mine, who I had played little league with and was playing against at this time in high school, lift his head and catch a ball in the dirt directly in the throat. I was on deck and immediately ran towards him, he stood up looked right at me and collapsed on the field. This can happen with both styles of masks.

So... use whatever feels comfortable. They both have benefits and drawbacks.

Just ask Alex Avila if concussions are possible, sure looked a bit loopy during Sox series. I looked into getting my 2016 the "pro style" but after a little web surfing I felt it that it was better not to chance it.  Another factor was the way the pro style seemed to move around so much: ie. throwing down to second etc. Much better for those collisions at the plate, maybe a thing of the past with the new rules. But in the end it comes down to personal preference.

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×