Skip to main content

I have a freshman (non-scholarship) that did not make the cut at a P5 D1, he was dropped from the team today.   What are the next steps.  For this conversation let's pretend it's a normal year and not a Covid year.

Is JUCO the main option?  Other ideas?

Does he have to enter transfer portal to drop to JUCO?  

If he was cut does he still need to be asked to be put in the transfer portal?

In the mean time he is packing it up and coming home, finishing the semester on-line and registering for the Spring while we figure out what it next incase this is the end.  I figure it's better for him to finish the year there with online classes and transfer to a closer school for next school year.

Other than baseball he said it sucked being stuck in a four cement wall dorm and not being allowed to do anything do to Covid.



-txdad

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Sorry to hear this TX.   Covid isn't making this easy on anybody.   Does your son have any intention to stay at this school because it offers an exceptional education or is he content to move on to a new baseball and educational opportunity?    I'm no expert on transfers, however HSBBWeb has experts like Rick at Informed Athlete that know every nook and cranny about transferring.   Additionally, you may want to familiarize yourself with NCAA transferring requirements and process (see below), so if you do talk to Rick you are up on all the lingo.   There is a lot of transfer lingo and concepts.  You can also call the NCAA with specific questions.   I know many people that have done that and got straight answers.

http://www.ncaapublications.co...ds/TGONLINE42020.pdf - D1 Transfer Guide, 4 year colleges

http://fs.ncaa.org/Docs/eligib...I_4-2-4_Transfer.pdf - D1 to D1 Tranfer Flow Chart

https://informedathlete.com/

Good luck!

My son had a similar experience last fall.

I know that this year has been the most adversity filled year in most peoples lives but sometimes a little more is needed to gain a clearer focus.

Here is what I know :

1- Juco is an option. However he must finish his associates degree(2 seasons) if he goes that route before he can transfer back to a D1

2- He can/should go into transfer portal (current school will put him in there once player requests). If he transfers to a D1- which I presume is probably a goal then he most likely(99.9887%) will not be able to play next spring and will have to sit out. (this is what my Son did)

3- He can transfer to a d2 or d3 and play immediately next spring.



the Transfer Portal is a interesting situation . player will most likely get contacted by many smaller schools that you may never even have heard of.

my advice is this:

1- go into transfer portal. He needs to ask his school and they will have him in there in a day.

2- contact coaches from schools that your son is interested in.

Write a very well written email with a extremely catchy subject line.  send to many .  we received a great response this way. however since it is October , most rosters are still being worked out.  you may get a better response after mid Nov.

3- keep all options open and do not make any quick decisions. more visits to schools will be needed if he wants to transfer

best of luck to your son.

Last edited by fishnsail

TX- I have a 2020 at a mid-major but is having a similar experience (lots of COVID lockdowns) and pretty much just sitting in his dorm room alone when he's not at practice.  He pretty much hates his college experience but loves the baseball...he's just letting it play out for now, but he could be in similar spot at semester break or May.  Thanks for posting and for the responses here, too.

Last edited by BPGuyfor2020

Sorry to hear TX! As stated, Rick can help with the rules. If he was not on scholarship and was not recruited, I believe that there are no transfer restrictions, but again, ask Rick.

Lots of good advice above. He needs to reach out to as many programs as he can to put the word out there. Getting in the portal as well. If he was good enough to get into a P5 as a walk on, he should be able to find a home somewhere.

Keep his head up, speak kindly of the former program, grateful for the opportunity, but it just didn't work out, learned so much and ready to work hard with new program. He needs to stay positive, even if it wasn't. New coaches don't want to hear the negatives. They want a player ready to move on and add to their program.

Most here will tell you things happen for a reason, and mostly work out for the better. Best of luck to your son and keep us in the loop as his journey continues. 

They have extended the free transfer waiver starting today, I think it said.  Rick would know.  A couple of things to ask his present school.

1.  Have them put him into transfer portal.  I don't think he has to but it will be good if he does.

2.  Ask them if they will give him a reference.  Don't know why he is leaving mid-semester but if it is not completely bad maybe they will give him a reference which will help or be open to talking to schools.  A lot of P5 coaches have connections with juco coaches so maybe they will help him get somewhere if they recruited him, at all, to start with.

@PABaseball posted:

Why not transfer right away? Wouldn't this create more opportunities and help with eligibility if he decided on another D1? By leaving after the fall, he would sit a year (spring 21 and fall 21) and be eligible for spring 22.

I'm sure there are plenty of mid majors/lower level D1 schools who would be happy to have a P5 dropdown.

Juco or D2 perhaps, the player has no game stats.

I would for a stable D2.

@keewart posted:

No scholarship/walk-on = No NLI = no one year sit out?  someone please correct me, barring the new waivers

NCAA Division I Bylaw 14.5.5.5 Baseball and Basketball—Midyear Enrollee. In baseball and basketball, a student-athlete who initially enrolls at the certifying institution as a full-time student after the conclusion of the first term of the academic year and qualifies for an exception to the one-year residence requirement shall not be eligible for competition until the ensuing academic year.

No waiver for this.

@keewart posted:

No scholarship/walk-on = No NLI = no one year sit out?  someone please correct me, barring the new waivers

If you transfer from a D1 to a D1 in the same season , regardless of if you received athletic $$ or were a preferred walk on then you must sit out that season.  You can try for a transfer waiver with the NCAA but that is a super long shot (we tried that route last year and appealed- with no success)

I suspect this rule will eventually be changed for the better, but as of right now it hasn't changed.

A question: He was non-scolly player. Was he recruited heavily or a unrecruited walk on? Is he truly a P5 D1 caliber player?  If not what level would he get playing time? (not to be critical just asking honest questions)

Your in TX so go check out Trinity in San Antonio. Championship level D3 that get's  D1 dropdowns and have a lot of D1 caliber players.  UTSA, UT Tyler also good options.

@BOF posted:

A question: He was non-scolly player. Was he recruited heavily or a unrecruited walk on? Is he truly a P5 D1 caliber player?  If not what level would he get playing time? (not to be critical just asking honest questions)

Your in TX so go check out Trinity in San Antonio. Championship level D3 that get's  D1 dropdowns and have a lot of D1 caliber players.  UTSA, UT Tyler also good options.

Trinty (TX) Average roster size for the last 4 years is > 40

Below is 2020 Distribution by State



image[5)

2020 Distribution by Position





image[6)

2020 Team Roster Insights  (Player Attrition)

image[7)

2019 Distribution by Position





image[8)

2018 Distribution by Position



image[10)

2017 Distribution By Position

image[11)

Attachments

Images (6)
  • image(5)
  • image(6)
  • image(7)
  • image(8)
  • image(10)
  • image(11)
@BOF posted:

A question: He was non-scolly player. Was he recruited heavily or a unrecruited walk on? Is he truly a P5 D1 caliber player?  If not what level would he get playing time? (not to be critical just asking honest questions)

Your in TX so go check out Trinity in San Antonio. Championship level D3 that get's  D1 dropdowns and have a lot of D1 caliber players.  UTSA, UT Tyler also good options.

UT San Antonio - 2020 Distribution by State

image[18)

2020 Distribution by Position.  The blue provides a hint they source might have large about of Transfer students.  They have increased this philosophy since 2017.

image[19)



2020 Team Roster Insights

image[20)

Attachments

Images (3)
  • image(18)
  • image(19)
  • image(20)
@BOF posted:

A question: He was non-scolly player. Was he recruited heavily or a unrecruited walk on? Is he truly a P5 D1 caliber player?  If not what level would he get playing time? (not to be critical just asking honest questions)

Your in TX so go check out Trinity in San Antonio. Championship level D3 that get's  D1 dropdowns and have a lot of D1 caliber players.  UTSA, UT Tyler also good options.

UT-Tyler is now a D2 school (As of 2020)



image[3)

2020 Distribution by Position

image[4)

2020 Team Roster Insights (High Turnover)

image[5)

2019 Team Roster Insights  (High Turnover)



image[6)

2018 Team Roster Insights (High Turnover)

image[7)

Attachments

Images (5)
  • image(3)
  • image(4)
  • image(5)
  • image(6)
  • image(7)
@TXsportsdad posted:

As of right now he is thinking JUCO so he can get back to DI, but we will see where that through process ends.

@TXsportsdad  We are in very interesting time, more baseball players than what is being demanded.

It will take about 3 years to recalibrate flow of human resources.

Regardless of the final landing point at a 4 year school,  look to see where the JUCO program has success with sending players to certain divisions.

As a Texas ballplayer, as Texas is very competitive, you might want to look at a JUCO program outside of Texas that has success placing D1 players in order to get the reps.

As stated in the movie "Fences", with Denzel Washington,  "Some times you need to take the straight line crooked".

For Example,  Iowa Western CC  2020

Distribution by State (Where are there players from)

01 Iowa Western Community College Distribution by State

2020 Distribution by Position



02 Iowa Western Community College Distribution by Position



Additional Team Roster Insights

  • Player Turnover Rate
  • Transfer In  (note, as accurate as listed by the school or player was previously on another school's roster, will not account for players that were never on roster)
    • E.g. you son was at a D1 school, tried out in the fall, didn't make the team
    • Decided to transfer schools, at his new school he tells his coach that he was at school xxx.
    • The coach may or may not publish the information, secondly he was never really on the team. So the definition of transfer is gray
    • image[8)
    • Number of Alumni at 4 year schools in 2020
    • 03 Iowa Western Community College JUCO Pipeline



IMHO, keep you options open,   being a big fish in a little pond that has success is not a bad thing.

The goal is to get quality reps and the right exposure.

Note, Midwest JUCOs are very successful in 4 year placement

Region 11 is very interesting.

Attachments

Images (4)
  • 01 Iowa Western Community College Distribution by State
  • 02 Iowa Western Community College Distribution by Position
  • 03 Iowa Western Community College JUCO Pipeline
  • image(8)
Last edited by CollegebaseballInsights

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×