Skip to main content

Not sure if this has been discussed at length before. I apologize if it has and this can be closed if it has, but I wanted to bring it up out of curiosity.

Recently, two prominent members of the basketball world came out and openly said that they were g-a-y. One is the president of the Phoenix Suns, and the other a former Villanova star.

At my school last year, there was a player on the lacrosse team who was a senior. His teammates voted him captain and after the captainship voting results were in, he requested a team meeting and came out to them. The reception was positive and the team went on to a successful year. There was a fairly lengthy article about the young man in the NY Times about the incident and now he is living in Los Angeles, has a talent agent and gets paid to travel the country as a motivational speaker for an organization that promotes open homosexuality (I forget the name of the organization specifically but I do know that this is currently what he does).

I'd like to get some people's opinions here. What do you think the reaction would be if more prominent athletes were to come out? What if professional baseball players were to begin coming out? More specifically, how do you honestly think you and/or your peers would respond if you or your son had a teammate who came out and was openly g-a-y?
Last edited {1}
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Truthfully, I don't think my son would care one way or the other if he had a g-a-y teammate as long as he was a good teammate. I think times have changed alot and people are more accepting than 20-30 years ago. I could never have that discussion with my grandparents, never. Prominent athletes have come out, and it has been a non-issue.

My personal viewpoint is that it is like religion & politics. People are willing to talk about it, but the second people start to impose their opinion & will on that topic...people get uncomfortable and offended. I think it is appropriate talk for the family dinner table but not so much on a message board. JMO.
When anyone comes out my reaction is to not give it any more attention than initial notice. I'm not in the generation of college students who have been indoctrinated to embrace the LGBT movement.

I don't care what anyone does in their bedroom. There's no reason for them to care what goes on in mine. I draw the line at gays sexually harassing (recruiting) others. It goes on in female college sports.

I'm not for the LGBT movement. I'm not against it. Live and let live. Don't intrude on other's lifestyle choices if it doesn't affect you.

(I'm betting this thread doesn't live twenty-four hours)
Last edited by RJM
Provocative topic.

Look, do I want any of my kids to be g-a-y? No. If they were, would I still love them? Yes.

I see this as a validation issue. I don't need to validate my hetrosexuality and I don't see the need to validate someone is g-a-y. I don't do sexual things in public like lip-lock my wife but I might occasionally give her a peck on the cheek or lips and vis versa. I don't want people putting their sexuality in my face and I promise to be respectful in return. I'd prefer that no one feel compelled to "come out" and highly prefer not to know about private things in the first place. I believe that don't ask don't tell is a good policy for our society.
Last edited by ClevelandDad
Previously I was of a mind that I preferred athletes and all celebrities keep their personal opinions and lifestyle choices to themselves. However, this recent rash of *** teens taking their own lives has changed my belief. The thought that these young people with their entire lives ahead of them feel they have no other choice but to commit suicide greatly saddens me. I've had conversations with my 3 kids (really young adults 22, 19 & 17) assuring them that Mom and I love them unconditionally for who they are and we are always there for them. Unfortunately, I think not all kids realize that and feel terribly alone in the world and fall into despair. This "It Gets Better" campaign, where *** celebrities have made public service announcements hoping to convince these kids their lives are worth living is extremely important.
So although, I personally do not care what my favorite Shortstop's sexual preference is, if his coming out publicly can save the life of a young fan, I am all for it.

As for my son, I honestly believe if the *** teammate can play and is a nice kid my son couldn't care less. Unfortunately, I am not so certain about some of his teammates.
quote:
Originally posted by ClevelandDad:
Provocative topic.

Look, do I want any of my kids to be g-a-y? No. If they were, would I still love them? Yes.

I see this as a validation issue. I don't need to validate my hetrosexuality and I don't see the need to validate someone is g-a-y. I don't do sexual things in public like lip-lock my wife but I might occasionally give her a peck on the cheek or lips and vis versa. I don't want people putting their sexuality in my face and I promise to be respectful in return. I'd prefer that no one feel compelled to "come out" and highly prefer not to know about private things in the first place. I believe that don't ask don't tell is a good policy for our society.
I agree with you. But now I'm going to provide the counter point to the way you and I feel. There are rights LGBT's don't have (marriage and partner benefits) that you and I have. This is why visible personalities "come out." They want people to know there are enough of them give rights consideration.
Last edited by RJM
I don't like homosexuality and really not comfortable around it overall. It doesn't mean I can't function around them but if given a choice I would rather not be around it. That being said if that's their choice or if they were born that way - it's none of my business. If that's the way they are then fine because I'm who I am and I'm not changing. I can't expect them to change.

If I had a g-a-y player then I'm going to deal with it and if he can play he will be in the lineup. My other players will not pick on him and I hope they accept him because, let's face it - g-a-ys aren't going away. We are all going to have to deal with them somehow.

People can change and acceptance can happen over time. I can truly say I wasn't raised with an open mind toward homosexuality. I can remember my dad making jokes and saying how it disgusted him. I have no earthly idea if he was ever around g-a-y people or not and I have no idea what he would have done if he ever came across them. So I wasn't taught to be open minded but I also wasn't taught to bash or hate them. I think (hope) this is where most Americans are right now. The number of parents who teach to hate others are getting smaller but they're still there.

I'm with fenwaysouth in that I'm not a fan of PDA - PERIOD. I don't care if you're straight, g-a-y, bi or whatever. I don't want to watch two people go at it hot and heavy. The peck on the cheek and hugs are fine but I can't stand the tongue rasslin. Here is where g-a-y people offend me when they are open in their PDA with each other around me. I don't want to watch that and it's the same way with a man and woman.

The whole ad campaign of "It's Gets Better" is a nice idea but when it comes to suicide the problem is much deeper than just getting picked on. Getting picked on is not unique to just g-a-ys. Fat, minorities, weak, slow, and all kinds of people are picked on. I've always been a bigger person even back in the day. I can't tell you how many times I've been called fata$$ and it does hurt. It does make you mad and I don't care how mentally tough you are it will affect you. I had good parents and sports to help me develop a mental toughness that allowed me to handle being called this. I still get called fata$$ and it still hurts and makes me mad but I don't let it define me.

I think this is where we're going in the wrong direction with helping teens who commit suicide. We need to teach these kids - not just g-a-ys - how to cope with these emotions because it's not going to stop. They will be called names, insulted and humiliated throughout their life - they need to learn how to handle these negative emotions that come with these things. I don't think these ad campaigns are doing that. Sad part is not everyone has good parents, sports or something to help them develop a strong self - image like I did.

It's different than what it was 20 - 30 years ago in terms of how it's handled in public. I just don't think that deep down the attitudes have truly changed that much. It's progress....not much but it is some.
I agree about the PDA whole heartedly, what ever happened to modesty. I also agree that Bullying takes all forms in our society and it must be addressed.
But I think the g-a-y bashing is different than the typical bullying, even racially or religious based bullying. At least the overweight kid, the black kid, the Jewish kid etc knows who they are and are accepted at home. These g-a-y kids often are in denial and hate themselves for who they are. They feel they can't go to their parents or friends for support or reassurance. Not many H.S. kids, especially athletes feel comfortable "coming out" so there is certainly no peer group for them to join. It appears in many cases the only consolation they can find is with a stranger they may identify with (a celebrity) to let them know they are not alone. The fact that we are having this discussion about other players reactions is all the proof we need that it is an issue. 50 years ago the discussion would be about how white kids and Coaches would accept the first black kid. The big difference is the black kid was certain he was black and his family was black and he didn't have to hide his race.
Again in a perfect world I would prefer not to know anyone's sexual preference. It's none of my business and I have enough to handle without worrying about theirs. But if it can help even one kid decide jumping off the bridge is not his only option then I support it. Here in NJ we had a tragedy where a freshman at Rutgers did jump. My son is a sophomore at RU so it hit close to home.
fenway- I am going to respectfully disagree. If the topic of homosexuality is not appropriate for message boards in your opinion, why not? Why shouldn't it be discussed? I think this is an interesting conversation to have, especially because this is directly correlated to baseball (I was not attempting to make it a political or religious argument, just wanted to see some opinions based on sports. Interesting responses so far). The fact that some people deem the topic not appropriate for public conversation proves that, in my mind, it is obviously an issue..right, wrong or indifferent.

fenway, I am not trying to be argumentative, I just am providing an answer for sake of discussion because I am actually interested in getting people's responses. I respect your opinions in every post you make and appreciate your response.

Here is the article I referred to: http://www.nytimes.com/2010/05...&sq=outsports&st=cse Whatever your opinion on the topic is, I think the article is interesting. Maybe it's selfishly because I know a lot of the people involved in the story, but I do.
I think our kids know a lot more g a y kids than we realize - I've discussed it a little bit with them, and the conversation ended with something like, "I know a lot of g a y kids, it's no biggie" They probably realize there are a lot more important issues facing them than to worry if little Johnny like boys or girls.

No one should be bullied over anything, and g a y couples should have the same rights as straight couples. in my opinion, in a perfect world
We have had to deal with this in the military for several years now. I have known of g a y soldiers for years and haven't really cared either way, as long as that person conducts him or herself in a respectable manner.

I look at it the same way in sports. Would I have a problem with my son sitting next to a g a y ballplayer on the team bus? No, I personally could care less. In general I have run into few homosexuals that flaunt their sexuality in an extreme manner. Just like I can't stand guys talking about their sexual proclivities with women I don't want to hear about g a y s bragging about the guys or gals they have gotten in the sack.

To be honest, the whole over the top rainbow **** that the militant homosexual lobby has pulled has done more to limit acceptance than anything else. When a guy in a bustier, makeup and a**less chaps tells a news outlet that all g a y s want is to be accepted like everyone else; well then...

Luckily I know of very few that are like that. Even here in the PNW.
I'm like most of the others on this topic in that I was never around any g-a-y people growing up. When I went into the Marines I DEFINITELY wasn't around any. And I can say that as far as I know, I've never been around any that I KNEW of. I guess my circle of friends and/or activities just never crossed paths with them here in rural Georgia.

With that being said, I am also agreeance with the others above in regards to the overall thought of why do they (young/older g-a-y adults) feel the gumption of wanting to "come out" and tell others this fact about themselves? I mean, seriously. I have never felt the pressing need to come out and tell anyone that I was heterosexual. Just because they are g-a-y, does it mean they must "come out" so deep within their own psyche they feel more accepted by the team/society? If not, then why? I don't need to know and quite frankly I don't want to know. Keep it to yourself. If you're baseball or (name the sport) talents and gifts are good enough to put you on the field, track, mat, gridiron, court, et al. then let THAT speak for yourself.

YGD
quote:
To be honest, the whole over the top rainbow **** that the militant homosexual lobby has pulled has done more to limit acceptance than anything else. When a guy in a bustier, makeup and a**less chaps tells a news outlet that all g a y s want is to be accepted like everyone else; well then...


I think there is a lot of truth to this and not just for g-a-ys but all groups seeking mainstream acceptance.

But you know think about that part of my statement - "seeking mainstream acceptance". When you want this then that means there probably has to be some sort of give and take in how you act in public to be accepted by the majority. Back in the 50's and 60's it was very obvious how the mainstream acted and what was accepted. The lines may be more blurred now in some areas but overall it's still pretty easy to figure out what is accepted by society. The super flamboyant ones seems to want everyone to conform to them when that's not what the majority want. That doesn't mean they can't be like that but it's pretty ridiculous for them to expect the mainstream to turn a blind eye and accept them.

You take a flamboyant g-a-y and an open g-a-y in a group the open one will find much more acceptance than the flamboyant one. That's natural in my opinion. I teach with a guy who's *** but he's not flamboyant nor does he hide it. I have the upmost respect for him because of the fact he's a great teacher and he doesn't force homosexuality down our throats. I've met his partner and he seems like a nice guy. We eat together at lunch with a group of people and all of us sit around and talk about everything. But it doesn't mean I'm going to hang out with him outside of school. The same can be said for the science teacher who's married to a woman because I think he's weird.

The parallel here is that if a guy is on the team and fits in then his teammates will accept him overall. Will they hang out outside of baseball - who knows? But not everyone on a team will hang out with others on the team. There were plenty of guys on my teams I never hung out with.

As for the bullying I pretty much agree with you Speedsdad. It's tough no matter what group is getting bullied and they all feel that nobody understands them and they question who they are. One thing I'm starting to see in schools are the fringe kids who claim they are g-a-y but probably not. They say it to garner attention from the mainstream. These are the kids who have the crazy hairstyle, outlandish outfits - for a lack of better term they are the flamboyant kids. They don't fit in with the other kids who are the brains and jocks and just cool kids. These kids are begging for attention and they figure one way to do is claim to be homosexual.

We had two boys hold hands walking down the hall and it created a stir. We had a few girls say they were dating and kiss in the hallways which created a stir. But the next week they were dating people from the opposite ***. I think things like this hurt g-a-y kids more because I'm guessing it's like a slap in the face. They probably see these kids as joking with something they are struggling with. They see how the mainstream kids handle the posers and it scares them in the attention.

I can't what I put above with absolute certainty but from what I see it leads me to think this way.

Teenage years are tough as it no matter what group you belong with. It does get better as they get older and this is where I think the ad campaign is hitting the nail on the head. But we need to help the kids now as to how to handle the feelings / emotions that come from being a confused teen.
quote:
Originally posted by 55mom:
I think our kids know a lot more g a y kids than we realize - I've discussed it a little bit with them, and the conversation ended with something like, "I know a lot of g a y kids, it's no biggie" They probably realize there are a lot more important issues facing them than to worry if little Johnny like boys or girls.


Same here. They know g*y kids already. If a player was a likeable guy, talented and dedicated to the team, and didn't make an issue out of being g*y, it probably wouldn't matter to my son. Alot more important things facing them than this. Pro's coming out should make it even easier.

I have no doubt there are many kids in HS choosing to be openly g*y to get attention, feel *special*, or out of rebellion. Sadly, this has a negative effect on the real g*y kids and their plight to be *ignored* for their sexual preferences. Once it is more accepted in the adult world, that motivator will go away.
quote:
My personal viewpoint is that it is like religion & politics. People are willing to talk about it, but the second people start to impose their opinion & will on that topic...people get uncomfortable and offended. I think it is appropriate talk for the family dinner table but not so much on a message board. JMO.


JH,

Disagreeing is always welcome. The topic is very polarizing and sensitive as is religion and politics. My point is that someone's sexual orientation is very personal, and a subject that is best discussed face to face as McIntosh did with his family. The story brings out the sensitivity and confusion that McIntosh faced. Message boards can sometimes be impersonal, and words can be miscontrued. I'm fine talking about homosexuality in general terms, but once it gets personalized I think it is best discussed privately not publically. After discussing with his family, he made the decision to go public. I can't even begin to understand what that was like.

As a whole, other peoples sexual, religous, and political orientation just don't excite me or inspire me. Action and words inspire me. As for the young man in the story, I'm happy for him and his team that they have been so accepting. I hope others can learn from his example or seek his advice as he did with another former college lacrosse player. If this was my son I would be proud of him.
In 1971," All in The Family" first aired, with Archie Bunker and all his built in prejudices, bigotry and ignorance who over time showed he was a well intentioned if often misguided white working class man.

Sitting on the hardwood floor next to my father in his favorite chair in my white working class neighborhood, I watched episode after episode and learned to laugh at my self, my prejudices, my bigotry and my ignorance.

In time, I moved from the floor to the couch and on to college where I was exposed to thoughts, practices and people of all kinds. Although my belief system was clogged with many rules and regulations about right and wrong, the overriding way taught me was one of tolerance and self-sacrifice. This is a way I wandered off occasionally but I always remembered this episode about Archie's football hero, Steve.
Judging Books By Covers
I have never had an issue with homosexuality. I have g-a-y cousins and g-a-y friends at school. To me, a person is a person regardless of what sexual feelings they may have.

I had a situation arise in high school that was interesting. I was in a music class (art & music are required electives and I'd rather try my hand at singing than drawing...I'm not exactly Picasso) in high school and became friends with a kid in the class who was openly g-a-y. He wasn't flamboyant or anything and we got along pretty well. Over the course of the year, however, it felt as though there was some tension between us. He would say weird things to me and would overreact to my comments as well.

One day I was online and received an instant message from a random address. I asked who it was, and the person told me it was a girl named Ashley from a neighboring town. She began hitting on me and sending me pictures of herself naked. The girl in the pictures was absolutely gorgeous. But the whole situation was just plain weird. Through some Googling, I found the pornographic website the pictures were from. This person was obviously fake.

I played along for a little while and got to the truth, the "girl" who was trying to coax me into exchanging pictures, was really the kid from my music class. I called him out on it and called him all sorts of inappropriate words.

I was pretty angry for a while. How dare he do that. How could he try to play a stupid game like that? Why would he think I'm g-a-y, or think I'm dumb enough to send naked pictures over the Internet to a "girl" I'd never met?

Truth be told, what he did was stupid. I never spoke to him again. But I didn't share the occurrence with my classmates either. I felt like that would be unnecessary, that it was not needed. He'd made a stupid mistake and I just wanted to move on from it. At first I had the mentality "stupid g-a-y person". But I realized that was wrong of me. That's a vast generalization that is inappropriate. His homosexuality didn't cause him to try to do what he did, he chose to.

My lighthearted policy with respect to homosexuality now is simply "If you don't try to touch me, you're cool in my book." Is this discriminatory? No, I don't think so. If a girl tried to hit on me that I wasn't sexually attracted to, it would probably cause awkward tension for the future. The same rule applies similarly in a g-a-y sense.

If I had a teammate who was openly g-a-y, I don't think it would change my view of him. It's his life, his choice (or genetics, not sure what the science of the matter has been determined to be). His personality doesn't...or shouldn't...change because of his sexual orientation. If it doesn't have any effect on his playing ability then I couldn't care less.

I wholeheartedly agree with the previous sentiment by some posters about PDA. It is completely unnecessary and awkward for any sexual relationship, whether heterosexual or homosexual, to occur. You don't need to be physically obsessive to show someone you have feelings for your significant other. In my opinion, PDA is a sign of insecurity in a relationship, but that's probably a discussion for another time (or another message board).
Last edited by J H
JH - Thanks for sharing. Good stuff!

PA Dino - Your All in the Family example is spot on. That episode crossed my mind too when I first read the post. The All in the Family series was so ahead of its time it is not even funny. Nothing compares to it IMHO. It made issues real, and exposed these topics for consideration just as JH has done in his orginal post.
Here's my question about having a g a y teammate. I ask this seriously, not to diminish anyone or anything.

We separate boys and girls bathrooms and locker room facilities, because there is sexual attraction between them, and it is roundly accepted that privacy considerations require boys and girls to be separated so they can undress without having someone who might be sexually attracted to them watching.

So, by the same token, would a g a y teammate have to use a separate locker room facility?
quote:
Originally posted by Rob Kremer:
Here's my question about having a g a y teammate. I ask this seriously, not to diminish anyone or anything.

We separate boys and girls bathrooms and locker room facilities, because there is sexual attraction between them, and it is roundly accepted that privacy considerations require boys and girls to be separated so they can undress without having someone who might be sexually attracted to them watching.

So, by the same token, would a g a y teammate have to use a separate locker room facility?
Years ago I lived in San Francisco. I belonged to The Bay Club. It was the largest health club facility in the city. Men's showers are communal. The locker room shower held about twenty men. I think it would be safe to say in a locker room shower with twenty men in San Francisco there had to be g@y men in the shower. I never gave it a thought. Actually I did one time to point out to my homophobic friend we were probably showering with g@y guys. He was upset his uncle was g@y.

One of today's issues is what to do with transgender people in terms of bathrooms and showers. A transgender was recently beaten in a McDonalds for being perceived to be in the wrong bathroom.
Last edited by RJM
quote:
Originally posted by J H:
I have never had an issue with homosexuality. I have g-a-y cousins and g-a-y friends at school. To me, a person is a person regardless of what sexual feelings they may have.

I had a situation arise in high school that was interesting. I was in a music class (art & music are required electives and I'd rather try my hand at singing than drawing...I'm not exactly Picasso) in high school and became friends with a kid in the class who was openly g-a-y. He wasn't flamboyant or anything and we got along pretty well. Over the course of the year, however, it felt as though there was some tension between us. He would say weird things to me and would overreact to my comments as well.

One day I was online and received an instant message from a random address. I asked who it was, and the person told me it was a girl named Ashley from a neighboring town. She began hitting on me and sending me pictures of herself naked. The girl in the pictures was absolutely gorgeous. But the whole situation was just plain weird. Through some Googling, I found the pornographic website the pictures were from. This person was obviously fake.

I played along for a little while and got to the truth, the "girl" who was trying to coax me into exchanging pictures, was really the kid from my music class. I called him out on it and called him all sorts of inappropriate words.

I was pretty angry for a while. How dare he do that. How could he try to play a stupid game like that? Why would he think I'm g-a-y, or think I'm dumb enough to send naked pictures over the Internet to a "girl" I'd never met?

Truth be told, what he did was stupid. I never spoke to him again. But I didn't share the occurrence with my classmates either. I felt like that would be unnecessary, that it was not needed. He'd made a stupid mistake and I just wanted to move on from it. At first I had the mentality "stupid g-a-y person". But I realized that was wrong of me. That's a vast generalization that is inappropriate. His homosexuality didn't cause him to try to do what he did, he chose to.

My lighthearted policy with respect to homosexuality now is simply "If you don't try to touch me, you're cool in my book." Is this discriminatory? No, I don't think so. If a girl tried to hit on me that I wasn't sexually attracted to, it would probably cause awkward tension for the future. The same rule applies similarly in a g-a-y sense.

If I had a teammate who was openly g-a-y, I don't think it would change my view of him. It's his life, his choice (or genetics, not sure what the science of the matter has been determined to be). His personality doesn't...or shouldn't...change because of his sexual orientation. If it doesn't have any effect on his playing ability then I couldn't care less.

I wholeheartedly agree with the previous sentiment by some posters about PDA. It is completely unnecessary and awkward for any sexual relationship, whether heterosexual or homosexual, to occur. You don't need to be physically obsessive to show someone you have feelings for your significant other. In my opinion, PDA is a sign of insecurity in a relationship, but that's probably a discussion for another time (or another message board).


To be honest JH, you should have reported this. If he tried this stuff with you I am pretty sure that he has tried it with others. He seems to have all the markings of a future sexual predator.

I've known quite a few homosexuals over the years and as a rule 99% of them DO NOT act like this. This guy is scary to be honest and possibly could be working down the path the wrong way.
Wklink- You are probably right. But that was sophomore year of high school. I was 15, 16 years old. My self-assurance was microscopic compared to what it is now. The social ramifications and time consuming process of attempting to report actions like this, at the time, seemed too much for me.

I still have mutual friends with this person and last I heard he is working at a local restaurant. If this were to happen now, I'd most certainly take more consideration into an action like you suggested. But at the time, I was probably just too immature and worried about the after-effect it would have on me personally.

Add Reply

Post
.
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×