Skip to main content

Replies sorted oldest to newest

So if I'm reading this correctly you want to put another fielder (in this case the SS) somewhere near the plate area and throw to them.

I see a couple of problems with this

1. The other fielder (SS) will be in foul territory and all fielders (with the exception of the catcher) has to be in fair territory at the time of the pitch.

2. For it to be a pitch it has to cross the plate or foul lines so if you want to put him in front of the plate or up the line to try and satisfy number one you now violate this.

3. If we're talking NFHS rules or most other rule sets (not all mind you) for amateur baseball you don't have to pitch to the batter. All you have to do is say "put him on".

4. Like Jimmy said - you're going to interfere with the batter and / or put the fielder in harm's way.

5. Like JH said - a pitcher should be able to put the ball in an area for a pitchout to intentionally walk a batter if that's what the rule set requires. To do anything else would hinder their development to move on in the game.

This is just not a good idea.
Zorro,
Your profile states you are a former college level player...

In your time as an active baseball player ( at any level) .... have you ever seen any coach,...any team,...at any level, attempt the play you are proposing?........

no, never....

it is illegal, a batter must be given an opportunity to swing at a legal pitch....
quote:
Originally posted by coach2709:
3. If we're talking NFHS rules or most other rule sets (not all mind you) for amateur baseball you don't have to pitch to the batter. All you have to do is say "put him on".



I'm sure this must have been covered off in another forum but why in the world does the NFHS need to take away an opportunity for play to proceed on the basis of a proper pitch out? Speed up the game, sure, but it also changes the game. If not, why wouldn't time conscious MLB do the same when they have far more talented athletes who would not be expected to screw up a pitch out?

Same holds true for the appeal rule. High School players should have to engage in an actual, in play, appeal. Not just allow anyone to ask an ump for an appeal.
I didn't answer the poll since this may be the dumbest question I've seen posted. I do not believe the poster played college baseball as stated in his profile. This sounds like a question from a preteen ball player trying to use his imagination.

If the ball is not received by the player who was in the catcher's box it's not a pitch. If there are runners on base it would be a balk. I have no idea on rules about positioning a player near the hitter to obstruct the hitter's view of the pitch. I don't know of any coaches yet who want their players to get killed.
Last edited by RJM
Coach 2709 gave the best answer in my opinion. The pitch must cross the foul lines. I was not proposing that the fielder play in foul territory; that is clearly illegal, except for the catcher. It still seems like a viable alternative to me in a league that does not play what we called speed-up rules. Seems to me that the fielder could just step across the foul line after the pitch is released. For those of you who do not understand why I asked the question, I would assume you have never seen a pitcher throw a wild pitch in that situation or throw a pitch too close to the plate which allowed the batter to hit it.
quote:
Originally posted by zorro2020:
Coach 2709 gave the best answer in my opinion. The pitch must cross the foul lines. I was not proposing that the fielder play in foul territory; that is clearly illegal, except for the catcher. It still seems like a viable alternative to me in a league that does not play what we called speed-up rules. Seems to me that the fielder could just step across the foul line after the pitch is released. For those of you who do not understand why I asked the question, *** I would assume you have never seen a pitcher throw a wild pitch in that situation or throw a pitch too close to the plate which allowed the batter to hit it.***
*** It's part of the game where the pitcher needs to acquire the appropriate skills. The alternative is NFHS does allow leagues to opt for signaling the hitter to first.

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×