Does anyone have any thoughts on it? Some people swear it is neccessary and others say don't do it.
Original Post
Replies sorted oldest to newest
quote:I understand the concept of elongating the muscles to create a fast contraction but I disagree with the idea of tension to creat quickness. The term reciprocal innervation is a fancy term that simply states that when muscles contract against each other maximum contraction is not achieved.
quote:Originally posted by MoDad:
I admit that I am not 100% sure of what "scapula loading" means; but if it is what I think it is, then I would not advise it...
quote:Originally posted by HiHardHeat:
Big ...
I don't disagree with the position... I just disagree with the naming of the term ...
Scapula loading is a huge misnomer. You are creating extension, lengthening the arm path and involving the chest muscles in the delivery.
... Call it "Chest Expansion" or "Path Lengthening" ... at least those have an element of the truth in it.... The Scapula is a bone ... how do you load a bone.
quote:Originally posted by HiHardHeat:
I guess I'm not making my point clearly .... The term is inaccurate and I personally don't care for it...
quote:Originally posted by Teacherman:
I see you identified.
quote:We have all heard ton's of "terms" over the years in baseball from "squish the bug", etc etc. "Scapula Loading" really is just another way of trying to get you into a position of maximum effort and the muscles near/around the scapula don't do anything but SLOW DOWN the efforts of your shoulder and chest muscles to violently throw your arm and shoulder forward. So much for the term, it's a gimmick.
quote:Work on the shoulder muscles, rotator cuff, legs, abs, chest, thighs ... That's were the speed is coming from.
quote:So much for the term, it's a gimmick.
quote:Does my son "load" according to the "scap loading" pics/theories/religion/etc (or whatever you want to call it)? Yes.
quote:Does he throw as hard as he can on every pitch? No, he's not a "Max effort" pitcher.
quote:Does he break 90? Yes.
quote:Originally posted by HiHardHeat:
BigHit15
It's really, really good seeing you back on the board. We missed you.
Thanks Teacherman. Horizontal Abduction is a much more descriptive term describing what is going on during the delivery.
Big: You've made my point for me ... on all of these muscles, the insertion point is the Humerus, which makes them part of the shoulder muscles. Of course you work on them, Anterior and Posterior. Working and strengthening the rotator cuff is critical.
Ogba: Nice first post ...
-------------------------
I really don't care one way or another which "professor of theology" someone follows, but I believe that you will make more progress if it's done in an "eyes on" situation. I believe that a pitching instructor/coach/guru or whatever you want to call it is more beneficial than a website, method or far distant expert who can't see you.
So ... why not max effort? This one probably does fall into the category of a religion for us. I've seen a lot of "max effort" high schoolers have to go under the knife for various reasons. I don't believe that they always have their growth plates closed, or have built sufficient bone density or muscle mass to allow the shock absorber action that is necessary to slow down their arm repeatedly from repeated max effort deliveries. Some guys mature earlier. For them it's fine.
As a person's body matures, then it's fine ... but my son still have some open growth plates that show on X-ray and has more physical maturing to do. He's a HS senior.
Teacherman: Every time I post, the points I'm trying to make are:
1). There is no one way to do anything. Look at the hitters/pitchers in the majors. They aren't carbon copies.
2). Extremes don't have a history of a high sucess rate. Yes pitchers can be sucessful throwing over the top at 12:30, but they are rare. Hitters can be out of sync and hit .300 in the pros.
... and still contend that you can't load a bone.
quote:Originally posted by obga:quote:So much for the term, it's a gimmick.
why dont you get out of your wheel chair and try it,
quote:Does my son "load" according to the "scap loading" pics/theories/religion/etc (or whatever you want to call it)? Yes.
lets see a video clip of him then...
quote:Does he throw as hard as he can on every pitch? No, he's not a "Max effort" pitcher.
good, then the kid that throws 95 will make it ahead of him and get paid more
quote:Does he break 90? Yes.
i smell bull ****, show us a clip with the radar gun at the end, this is the internet you cant fool me, i know a 15 year old that is having trouble breaking 90 consistantly that throws with the intent of a hungry wolf
so i just devoured hisoftheat, anyone wanna argue weighted baseballs dont work either?
quote:... Go ahead Teach work him over real good and he will go away...
quote:Originally posted by Coach May:
Obga we dont attack peoples kids here. We dont attack peoples kids period.