Skip to main content

Augh.

My son, who tore his ACL and meniscus very early in the season (at a new school) and had surgery to repair them, just heard the news that his college is closing. So now what?

Do the same sorts of transfer rules apply? What about a medical red shirt? He transferred from a D2 to NAIA. Does he have to stay at an NAIA?


Also, is anybody an "expert" at eligibility as it relates to medical redshirts, transfers, etc? This is very confusing and tricky to me....

Thank you all in advance.....
Last edited {1}
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

There is a father-poster both on this message board and in the St. Louis newspaper
s prep section that is very knowledgeable on thes matters. His call sign is is "Gitnby". I would suggest that you reach out and PM him...Good luck with the ACL recovery. My son is five weeks out from ACL and meniscus surgery and it has been rough on him...
Let's separate this into two aspects.
First, transferring is not a problem: The school has announced that it is closing, which means that it is also discontinuing the baseball program. For transfers to NAIA, as long as the player has a cumulative 2.0, and a release from the previous school, he is eligible immediately (Article 5G.1).

In NCAA D1, Bylaw 14.5.5.2.6 applies, and it provides for immediate eligibility assuming the player is academically eligible. In D2, the bylaw is numbered 14.5.5.3.6, but is basically the same as D1. In D3, the player is immediately eligible as long as he would have been athletically and academically eligible at the previous college.

For discontinued sports, it doesn't matter that he already transferred once from a 4 year school.

Secondly, the rules for a hardship waiver (frequently referred to as a "medical redshirt") vary among the divisions, but it sounds like he would qualify.
1) A doctor must have diagnosed and documented the injury.
2) The injury needs to be incapacitating for the rest of the season.
3) The injury must have occurred before the player has been in a threshold number of games, which depends on the rules of the new division.

A torn ACL and meniscus with attendent surgery likely will meet the first two requirements. For NAIA, the player must not have played in more than 8 games. NCAA D1 requires that the injury occurred in the first half of the season, and that the player participated in not more than 30% of the games. For D2, the player must not have been in more than 20% or the games. D3 uses one third.

The request for a hardship waiver needs to originate at his new school and is ruled on by the new conference. Make sure that you keep the medical documentation.
Last edited by 3FingeredGlove

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×