Skip to main content

There has been quite a bit of talk about pitchers using pine tar and other stuff to increase spinrate on pitches.

Pitchers have always done stuff like this but apparently pitchers are now using more tacky stuff to get an even better effect.

Eno sarris from the athletic has talked to guys behind the scenes and now claims that for example the brand spider tack would be +300 to +500 RPM on spin rate which if you combine it with pitch design to optimize the spin direction really makes balls hard to hit and increase strike outs.

Some have argued that pitchers always have done it and this increases control and thus Batter safety but HBP actually are on a very high level right now so that probably doesn't work so well.

Also with guys testing new substances the level playing field argument isn't that great anymore either.

Does mlb need to enforce something against that?

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

There are certain high level college pitchers that other teams suspect of doing it.  It is a given that certain pitchers touch a certain place on their uniform before a pitch when a new ball is put in or every so many pitches.  I have wondered why they would not object to it but I've been told that there is almost one pitcher on every college team that does it so if you turn the other team in they will reverse it back on you.  Man code I reckon.

Shildt of the Cardinals told the truth.  It depends upon who you are and the organization you play for.  Some of these pitchers are laughing at MLB and know nothing is going to happen.  The rules need to be enforced.  Right now this has turned the game into a mockery of the game.  On one film review on MLB Central, they showed a pitch going straight sideways from an overhead pitcher.  The following comment was that they could not get a whiffle ball to break like that. 

Last edited by CoachB25

Manfred is a terrible commissioner.  As noted by others above, the stuff going on is obvious and observable, simple to catch in the act, and easy to investigate, easy to put an end to.  He let players cheat to win a World Series, without consequence for god's sake.  It isn't surprising he'd let a little thing like spitballing go on.

I think manfreds plan is to do it like the Mitchell report where you do an investigation but no punishment kinda as a warning and then next year enforce it.

That way you give players enough time to get off the juice to avoid a big scandal with dozens of guys getting caught.

That's why they are collecting caps and balls and Analyse them behind the scenes.

@Dominik85 posted:

I think manfreds plan is to do it like the Mitchell report where you do an investigation but no punishment kinda as a warning and then next year enforce it.

That way you give players enough time to get off the juice to avoid a big scandal with dozens of guys getting caught.

That's why they are collecting caps and balls and Analyse them behind the scenes.

This approach has no deterrent value... hence the fact that they are doing this on the heals of a major cheating scandal without any fear of reprisal.  Once this is resolved he should expect yet another type of cheating scandal since it is obvious he let's them get away with it.

@mattys posted:

pitchers have been doing it forever. if a pitcher, especially in HS where they aren't likely PO, has "sticky stuff" on his hands, who's to say that it isn't just pine tar from his last AB?  ditto for the NL where pitchers hit.

This is methodical, not some random act of pine tar from their last AB...most relievers never touch a bat and they are throwing nasty, unhittable pitches...

Last edited by fly996

10-game ban for foreign substances:

https://www.espn.com/mlb/story...d-suspended-10-games

Washington Post says:

But the notion of enhanced enforcement appears to have been some kind of deterrent. In the 12 days before June 3, Major League hitters hit .233, walked 9.1 percent of the time, struck out 24.3 percent of the time, and experienced a home run-to-fly ball ratio of 12.7 percent. In the 12 days after, those same hitters hit .246, walked 8.4 percent of the time, struck out 23.3 percent of the time, and experienced a home run-to-fly ball ratio of 14.4 percent.

The sudden increase in offensive performance is noteworthy in multiple ways. It does seem to suggest that the threat of punishment is limiting pitcher advantage over hitters — which, one could assume, meant those substances were giving pitchers that advantage in the first place.

https://www.washingtonpost.com...rcement-suspensions/

Look, my son is a pitcher. He has never used anything, not even rosin. He doesn’t sweat a lot, so I guess that is how he gets away with it. The rules that are on the book should be implemented. Period. Selfishly, I want him to be on a level playing field when competing against other guys and trying to move thru the professional ranks. Just one dad’s opinion.

@younggun posted:

Look, my son is a pitcher. He has never used anything, not even rosin. He doesn’t sweat a lot, so I guess that is how he gets away with it. The rules that are on the book should be implemented. Period. Selfishly, I want him to be on a level playing field when competing against other guys and trying to move thru the professional ranks. Just one dad’s opinion.

The bolded is spot on and reappears through our society over and over again.

Kid on my sons summer team was using pine tar last night. He should probably figure out how to throw more strikes before trying to get more spin.

Throwing more strikes is the last thing that lots of young pitchers ever think about.  You can thank social media, travel ball, the showcase circuit, unqualified instructors, and the general obsession with high velo for all that. Usually the rubber meets the road when a pitcher gets to college and if a kid can’t throw strikes he isn’t gonna see the mound. But the other night, in game 3 of a super regional, Notre Dame ran a reliever out there (in a high leverage situation) that was 97 - 98 every pitch - but he couldn’t throw 3 strikes in 7 pitches and the game got away from ND in that inning. SMH

But the notion of enhanced enforcement appears to have been some kind of deterrent. In the 12 days before June 3, Major League hitters hit .233, walked 9.1 percent of the time, struck out 24.3 percent of the time, and experienced a home run-to-fly ball ratio of 12.7 percent. In the 12 days after, those same hitters hit .246, walked 8.4 percent of the time, struck out 23.3 percent of the time, and experienced a home run-to-fly ball ratio of 14.4 percent.

So 45% of the at-bats have no ball in play (other than HR)... This can't possibly be good for the game.  I know it's competitive sport, but in the end it is really about entertainment.  If it is not entertaining it will lose fans, draw fewer kids to the game, lose revenue and eventually have a bad ending.

@Smitty28 posted:

So 45% of the at-bats have no ball in play (other than HR)... This can't possibly be good for the game.  I know it's competitive sport, but in the end it is really about entertainment.  If it is not entertaining it will lose fans, draw fewer kids to the game, lose revenue and eventually have a bad ending.

Probably,  though that thought reminds me of old-school post-apocalypse science fiction novels, where the obliteration of mankind usually results in some kind of small resurrection of civilization in its purest form.  So maybe baseball goes the way of the velociraptor and soon afterwards returns underground with pickup teams playing with broomsticks and tennis balls and no gloves, and it's more fun to play and to watch.

@JCG posted:

Probably,  though that thought reminds me of old-school post-apocalypse science fiction novels, where the obliteration of mankind usually results in some kind of small resurrection of civilization in its purest form.  So maybe baseball goes the way of the velociraptor and soon afterwards returns underground with pickup teams playing with broomsticks and tennis balls and no gloves, and it's more fun to play and to watch.

Not sure about all that... A better parallel might be soccer, you wait around for an hour and a half for one or two amazing moments.  Or an Evander Holyfield fight where you wait around for an hour and absolutely nothing happens.

@Dominik85 posted:

Tyler glasnow got a forearm injury that might turn into TJ and blames the rule enforcement for it as that would have required him to change his grip

I believe this.  My son has pronators syndrome which causes forearm tightness.  He has small hands and says he has to grip the ball tight to have control, which causes his arm to tighten up.  If he uses a loose grip, no tightness, but also far less control.  I would think with as hard as guys throw, they would prefer they have more control than less.  The game is being elevated on all levels.  Exit velocity is getting higher, pitch velocity is getting higher.  Guys have to adjust.  Just another elevation of the game.  Learn to hit nasty pitches.

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×