Standballman,You have this right on. Ichiro can drive the ball if he wants to by changing his swing to the “classic power swing” at will. He was challenged by the press last year at home to do so in batting practice so he obliged them and took 20 power swing and promtly lost 12 of them in the outfield stands shutting them all up.
His current approach puts the ball on the ground because of the upwards trajectory of the barrel causeing top spin predominantly.
Pgstaff,quote:
“Somehow this contact on the way down thing got popular a few years back”
Actually this is as old as the hills and twice as dusty, the effects of round on round objects has been known and taught for as long as I can remember and none of my clients for 35 years have had any problems with this Cue. Contact with barrel path heading down can not really happen and it is only the instructors that do not get this that there is a problem. The opposite problem of contact on the way up is much more of a problem when trying to get lift out of a line drive. There is 100’s of times more overly upper cutters with problems than the very few overly downers.
quote:
“We see lots of kids and when we see a good player that has been taught this we cringe.”
You must have double cringed when you first saw “the LaBron of baseball”.
When I see an uppercut swing on these batters I don’t cringe anymore I just shake my head now and thank the instuctors for their swing perseptions.
quote:
“Understand there are things coaches say like "stay on top". But these days there aren't many "good" coaches that want their hitters making contact on the way down.”
While this is true you can not attain slight vectoral difference to create back spin predominance unless you perform a straighter path to the ball.
quote:
”Nearly all pitches are moving downward to some extent.”
All overhead pitchers balls head down, no acceptions here, they all have different downwards degrees with high velocity 12/6 fastballs being the least at about a 3 degree angle down.
quote:
“Why would someone want the bat to also be going downward”
To over emphasis the teach to attain just slight barrel to ball vectoral differand where the barrel exit’s just below the ball exit causing bottom spin exit on the ball causing lift and carry.
quote:
“ This would take exactness and even if it created back spin the actual contact would be weaker”
The contact will be stronger in that it is traveling more with gravity and you gain forearm /wrist contractions to maintain barrel rotational ineria. Much more powerful and all approaches strive for this same exactness.
quote:
“Level to the ground would be better than down”
These are only general explanational cues and people need to quit over exagerating their importance being that none of them even come with a detailed explanation as to what they mean when someone disagrees with them or for them.
Level to the ground will give contact this vectoral difference that is desireable but may be to much vectoral difference if actually performed that does not happen even with a downwards attempt.
quote:
”To drive a nail the hammer strike needs to hit the nail squarely at the angle the nail is at.”
This would create a knuckleball exit with the ball, can you immagine trying to catch a knuckleball coming at you at 120 MPH if you were an infielder? This would be preferable if it could be done. There is most always vectoral difference, I believe the backspin producing one is preferable.
quote:
I think there's too much emphasis placed on creating back spin
I start with this scenario, teaching from exit back to stance with all my clients so they understand this first. Then they have a higher incidence of producing back spin instead of the ball dying top spin. It is much more difficult to produce backspin hence forth the over exageration towards it!
quote:
“Back spin is a good thing, but trying to force it by swinging down through the ball requires perfection and is not good IMO.”
All approaches create this try at perfection, why settle for top spin predominance by telling batters it is OK to produce top spin with their natural uppercuts at contact?