I was just wondering how people would rate the "5 tools" in order of importance for position players. I know it varies somewhat from position to position but for an overall player. Also are some tools and combinations of tools more rare then others? A lot of talk about pitchers baseline abilities to progress to the next level. Just trying to figure out what position players baseline skillsets need to be.
Replies sorted oldest to newest
I am curious too.
For obvious reasons it is different for each position, a SS needs to have huge defensive skills and a big arm. A 1B needs to plug the gap and be able to hit the ball out of the park occasionally, having range and a big arm isn't quite as important. 3B don't need the range of a SS but he needs quick reaction's and a gun, he too should rake once in awhile. At 2B it sometimes is what a coach decides what he needs, you can put your value on a average glove with a big bat, or go with a great defensive player that makes all the plays without a big arm or bat.
What of the 6th tool?
Bob
I think if there is a tool in addition to the five physical tools it would be a mental tool. A player needs to be be mentally prepared for the next play he will have to make .
For the HS level, hitting well for average and having a good glove are of high importance. In regards to progressing to the next level, the other three become differentiators.
This is a little weird. Are you going to clone baseball players?
For the HS level, hitting well for average and having a good glove are of high importance. In regards to progressing to the next level, the other three become differentiators.
This is a little weird. Are you going to clone baseball players?
I am going to have to wait on the cloning until after I see how my son turns out. He did run into some baseball genes though. They must have skipped generation. I guess it has something to do with how I would rate my son as a player. He has his strengths and weaknesses .I just am trying to grade him out with little knowlege of how to.
1. Hit for Average
2. Strong Glove
3. Foot speed
4. Strong Arm
5. Hit for power
None of it matters without the intangibles such as passion, determination, heart and instinct. But the intangibles don't matter either without some tools.
Agree with Florida! If you cannot rake, then you will not see the diamond.
Lefty
