how far will u let a coach argue with you before u toss him?
Original Post
Replies sorted oldest to newest
That really depends.....it depends on the call, the coach and what is said.... I am very wary of umpires who would have a set ejection point..... As an Umpire you have to let a coach have his say. As long as it does not get profane or personal, Im going to listen....
There is a point where you cant go further...each instance has to be judged on its own merit.
I want to add this part from a previous post of mine. If you have clearly blown a call, (and I have) an umpire with any experience will most probably give that coach leeway in his complaint.....
As long as he avoids profanity and keeps it within reason, Im going to let him complain....I do not want to compound my mistake with an ejection....so I will do my best to keep him in the game and take my lumps....
Also a Coaches prior history of good behavior, Game and Rules Knowledge and relationships with umpires will give some coaches extra leeway in some disagreeable situations
There is a point where you cant go further...each instance has to be judged on its own merit.
I want to add this part from a previous post of mine. If you have clearly blown a call, (and I have) an umpire with any experience will most probably give that coach leeway in his complaint.....
As long as he avoids profanity and keeps it within reason, Im going to let him complain....I do not want to compound my mistake with an ejection....so I will do my best to keep him in the game and take my lumps....
Also a Coaches prior history of good behavior, Game and Rules Knowledge and relationships with umpires will give some coaches extra leeway in some disagreeable situations
I agree with piaa_ump, you really can't have a drop dead line on arguements other than certain words. If a coach comes out and has a discusion I will talk to him and explain the ruling. If he comes screaming at me, I will let wind down a little and then explain. If he cares to simply berate and not discuss he will probably leave. If he comes out hot and I let him vent, takes the ex[alnation, then goes to the dugout then no problem.
The ones that simply want to rant and rave and has no basis in rules or cares not to listen to my interp, or curses will probably take the day. A long way of saying it's a case by case call.
The ones that simply want to rant and rave and has no basis in rules or cares not to listen to my interp, or curses will probably take the day. A long way of saying it's a case by case call.
Piaa and Michael, Very good posts by both of you IMO. As in the past I think you serve your profession well.
When you do make a mistake-a call that you know should have gone the other way- what do
you say to the coach when he comes out to "discuss"?
Once ,on my way out to "discuss" a clearly blown call the ump met me half way and before
I could make an a$$ out of myself he says, "Sorry, coach, I blew it!". Stopped me dead in my tracks and I think I just said "No Problem"
and turned back and tried to hide my smile.
Would be interesting to hear some other stories.
When you do make a mistake-a call that you know should have gone the other way- what do
you say to the coach when he comes out to "discuss"?
Once ,on my way out to "discuss" a clearly blown call the ump met me half way and before
I could make an a$$ out of myself he says, "Sorry, coach, I blew it!". Stopped me dead in my tracks and I think I just said "No Problem"
and turned back and tried to hide my smile.Would be interesting to hear some other stories.
Moc,
Of the calls I've missed, usually its been obvious to all. Over the years I've posted a few of them here.
The biggest mistake in that instance is to try and cover your backside.
I called a ball Foul just before it hit a rock and bounced fair....Nothing left to do but do as your post said, Coach, I blew it....but it has to stay foul.....
I've been screened by a catcher when a batter hit a ball down the third base line, I saw the ball bounce foul and I called foul....problem is it had hit fair first and I had not cleared the catcher fast enough to see it......but the coaches, both dugouts and all the fans and the hot dog vendors saw it fair......
I was doing a solo game when a batter hit into a 6-4-3 double play...I busted out towards the mound to make the call, I got the out at second and made the call at 1st...double play...except at my angle it looked like the 2nd baseman was right on top of the bag when he took the relay.......in reality he was no where near it.....nothing I could do but take my lumps....
Honesty is the best policy...it wont keep you from a chewing out, but it will maintain your integrity and thats what coaches want from you anyway.
Of the calls I've missed, usually its been obvious to all. Over the years I've posted a few of them here.
The biggest mistake in that instance is to try and cover your backside.
I called a ball Foul just before it hit a rock and bounced fair....Nothing left to do but do as your post said, Coach, I blew it....but it has to stay foul.....
I've been screened by a catcher when a batter hit a ball down the third base line, I saw the ball bounce foul and I called foul....problem is it had hit fair first and I had not cleared the catcher fast enough to see it......but the coaches, both dugouts and all the fans and the hot dog vendors saw it fair......
I was doing a solo game when a batter hit into a 6-4-3 double play...I busted out towards the mound to make the call, I got the out at second and made the call at 1st...double play...except at my angle it looked like the 2nd baseman was right on top of the bag when he took the relay.......in reality he was no where near it.....nothing I could do but take my lumps....
Honesty is the best policy...it wont keep you from a chewing out, but it will maintain your integrity and thats what coaches want from you anyway.