Skip to main content

Had another interesting discussion today with a couple of high school baseball coaches. We talked at length about wood vs metal bats. One coach was all for making the change to wood. He cited all of the normal reasons people give for making the switch; a more true feel to the game, safer for the defenders and it makes the hitters better in the long run. Valid points to be sure. The other coach countered with the fact that you hardly ever see people dodging pieces of a broken metal bat at his games so he wasn’t convinced on the safety issue. And with his current budget, his program couldn’t afford to keep buying his team new wood bats all season anyway. Valid points as well.

I guess I’m one of those “have my cake and eat too” kind of people. When my kid is pitching, I love to see everyone using wood. When he’s hitting though, hearing that “PING” and watching the ball go and go kind of makes me smile… I’m obviously hopeless. crazy

Should High School and College programs be required to use wood?
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I believe that more leagues will switch to wood or variations of wood in the coming years, at least I sure hope so. With the wood composites that are available these days, durability is a straw dog that proponents of metal bats keep falling back on. You can find very durable wood composite or laminate bats these days.

One organization that made the switch to wood mandatory this year was the American Amateur Baseball Congress (AABC). For 2009, the Stan Musial, Connie Mack and Don Mattingly leagues will only be using wood, wood composite or wood laminate bats. No metal bats will be allowed. This is a change in the right direction, IMO.
Beast - The guy I was talking to gets couple of new aluminum bats donated to his program every year. He's afraid that if the switch was made to wood he might not be able to keep pace with replacements for his team. Even composites crack after a while. Your right though if the players provide their own that shouldn't be an issue.

At my kid's school for instance the players all provide their own wood.
quote:
Originally posted by The Beast:
quote:
Should High School and College programs be required to use wood?

Yes.
No high school I know of buys their players bats.
So I don't buy that argument.
I agree. For $300 (for the metal) I can buy six good wood bats. If someone purchases less expensive equipment ($150 for a metal bat), they could buy six $25 bats.

Back in 13U we played in a wood bat tournament where the tournament supplied the bats. They were $15 a piece (the program buys in bulk). My team broke two bats in five games (no they didn't whiff a lot).
Last edited by RJM
I believe all high school and college baseball should go to wood.
Their is no good reason to have a 6'4" 235lb. 20 year old on his way to pro ball use a metal bat. To see some the monster HR they hit is almost ridiculous.

I don't think it could be a money issue for colleges like some of the high schools claim so I don't understand why the NCAA doesn't go to wood. I think it would be a better game.
I watched him play this weekend. The kid has a cannon for an arm! He started at catcher then moved to centerfield, shortstop and then to third. He looked pretty comfortable at each position but I especially liked him behind the plate. Quick reactions and nice at receiving the ball. Oh and yes he did go deep one time. He pulled it to right and yes he was using metal...
Very true OS8. I'll share a story. Opening day last year I went to a double header with OU at UCLA. Top of the 8th with the Bruins sitting on a 2 run lead. OU gets a guy on with two outs. Coach Golloway from OU puts Mike Gosse in to pinch hit. This kid is all of 5-7 and maybe 160, not your quintessential big stick guy. Personally I thought the coach was going for a trick play or something! Anyway, a couple of pitches later and we had a tie game. Had I known a little more about Gosse, I wouldn't have questioned the coaches reasoning. Gosse ended up the season leading the Sooners in batting average and had a total of 8 long balls to boot. Later on in the year I saw him again, swinging wood this time. And guess what, the kid could still mash the ball. Just another example of not having to be a giant to play big.

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×