Skip to main content

Last night in my son's game, runner on 2nd attempts steal to 3rd. The catcher pops up and attempts a throw down to 3rd with RH batter at the plate. Batter rises straight up from his batting crouch and stays still. The catcher hits the batter in the act of throwing and the ball goes off line. The umpire rules that the batter was in the batters box and therefore could not interfere with the throw.

I had always understood the batter should make an attempt to get out of the way. In this case, the batter stood straight up, making himself as tall as possible.

Is this a judgement call?
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

I beleive the batter is allowed in the box at all times even in stealing home situations (not passed ball/wild pitch situation). Not sure of the phraseing but I think it has to do with the "bang bang" timing -- if he left the box and interfered that would be different -- say a throw to second and batter crossed the plate. The assumption is the batter is watching the pitch and does not have time to get out of the way.

Catchers are taught to step back on throws to third - It think noidea
Thanks for the quick response, Former. If the cather attempts to make a throw and hits the batter while the batter is in the box, do we just play on?

Last night, the umpire said 'As long as the batter is in the box, he can't interfere.' It appears there was more to the ruling, so the ump must have been saying 'He didn't attempt to get in the way and he's entitled to the box.'
I posed nearly an identical question on another board quite a while ago. The answer was that, in the case of a runner stealing 3rd, the batter can't resonably be expected to get out of the way that fast. As long as he doesn't intentionally (here it comes) - in the umpires judgement - intefere with the catcher it's not interference. The batters box isn't an automatic safe zone where the batter can do anything he wants, but as long as he doesn't do anything intentional to interfere with the catcher he should just stay put. Depending on where the catcher fields the pitch he should be throwing either in front of or behind the batter, never over him.
Last edited by StyleMismatch

Add Reply

Post
.
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×