To be a good leadoff, you simply must understand your role: To be the ignitor of the offense. It really doesn't matter HOW you get your offense firing on all cylinders...it only matters that you CAN. I have had leadoff hitters that walk a ton, some with high averages, some with great speed, etc....but the way I judge their effectiveness comes down to one concept: RUN PRODUCTION. Are we scoring runs with them in that slot? Do they generally find a way to get us rolling? I personally don't care about a guy being a "conventional" leadoff guy...I simply need a guy that provides the spark for our team offensively.
Good luck - leadoff is a lot of pressure, but it is a great role for a confident player.