Skip to main content

OrlandoSentinel.com
HIGH SCHOOLS
Montverde baseball team on probation
Tania Ganguli

Sentinel Staff Writer

October 16, 2007

The Florida High School Athletic Association placed Montverde Academy's baseball team on restrictive probation through the 2008-09 season and fined the Lake County private school $10,000.

As a result of its probation, which is effective immediately, Montverde's baseball team will not be allowed to participate in the state playoffs in 2008 and '09. Additionally, Montverde is limited to 20 regular-season games and banned from playing any out-of-state or out-of-country teams.

In a letter sent to the FHSAA on Monday, Montverde headmaster Kasey Kesselring wrote Montverde did not plan to appeal.

"Montverde Academy respects the investigative process of the Florida High School Athletic Association," Kesselring said in a two-sentence statement. "The academy has worked cooperatively with the association to resolve any potential issues, has accepted responsibility for those issues in which the academy was in error and will work diligently in the future to avoid any violations of FHSAA standards."

The investigation began May 22, after the Sentinel reported Andrew Parks, Montverde's baseball coach and dean of the middle school, had traveled to Puerto Rico for an admissions event in the summer of 2005.

The Sentinel also reported Montverde was in contact with a third-party agent, Pedro Leon, to locate students. Montverde officials said Leon was one of several agents around the world that the school uses to help attract students. Leon runs a program that helps place Puerto Rican athletes in colleges.

In the spring of 2007, Montverde's baseball team went to the state final four for the first time in its six years of existence. Seventeen members of the 18-player team, which lost to Tallahassee North Florida Christian in the state final, were from Puerto Rico.

The FHSAA's investigation found that Parks and former dean of admissions Alan Whittemore attended a two-day exposure camp run by Leon in Salinas, Puerto Rico. The two administrators spoke with baseball players who were working out, and Parks actively participated in player evaluations. Parks and Whittemore were housed and fed for one night in the same dorm and cafeteria as the players. Five students who attended the camp later enrolled at Montverde.

The FHSAA also found that Parks, who did not return a phone call, participated in an open house conducted by Whittemore at a hotel outside San Juan, Puerto Rico. The letter stated that "families of baseball players mostly attended the open house."

In response to the findings, Montverde reprimanded Parks and said he will not travel to Puerto Rico for "any admission open houses in the future nor be present or participate in any camps held in Puerto Rico." The school also said it will "distance its relationship with the third party and encourage all prospective students to inquire directly through the admissions office."

At the time of the violation the policy stated that "recruiting programs of any kind cannot be conducted by coaches or any members of the school's athletic staff." Because coaches at many schools also serve other administrative roles, the policy was altered in an FHSAA board meeting in June.

As part of the investigation, the FHSAA spoke with Montverde officials, Leon, Whittemore, Parks, two Montverde players and parents. One player said Leon had told him Parks would be at the sports complex on the day of the camp.

"There were other coaches," said the player, whose name was redacted from the document. "But they were college coaches."

Tania Ganguli can be reached at tganguli@orlandosentinel.com.

Copyright © 2007, Orlando Sentinel
Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Football also has their problem:

http://www.modbee.com/2103/v-print/story/94905.html

The Modesto Bee

Posted on Tue, Oct. 16, 2007
Franklin High football team penalized for recruiting Samoan players

By WILL DeBOARD
wdeboard@modbee.com
last updated: October 16, 2007 06:25:15 PM

LODI — The Franklin High School football team of Stockton was severely penalized today for recruiting players from American Samoa.

Among the sanctions from the CIF Sac-Joaquin Section, which governs high school sports from Sacramento to Merced:


Forfeit of 19 victories for the past three seasons.
A ban from playoff eligibility through the 2011 season.
Franklin can continue to compete in the San Joaquin Athletic Association, but its results will not count through the 2011 season.
The three American Samoan players on this year’s team are ineligible for all athletic competition through the end of this school year.
The section will appoint two individuals to monitor the Franklin football program through the 2014 season. Those people will be retired administrators, assigned to review all transfer eligibility situations and all other duties as requested by the section.

“The litany of evidence is overwhelming and irrefutable, and frankly it’s very disturbing,” said section Commissioner Pete Saco. “This was a calculated scheme. We regret the actions of a few have impacted an entire school.”

Saco said the section found 54 violations involving 10 players from American Samoa over the past three seasons. No other Franklin teams or players are affected.

The penalties do not cover football coach Tom Verner because the section has no jurisdiction over coaches, Saco said.

Verner is a wealthy real estate developer who has served as football coach for the past 14 seasons.

The section announced Sept. 25 it had completed a six-month investigation into the Franklin program. That report asserts members of the Franklin coaching staff paid air fare and room and board for American Samoan players. It also asserts Eleimanu Seumaala, the mother of Franklin assistant coach Jeff Seumaala, illegally contacted each of these players on American Samoa.

Verner, the Stockton Unified School District and Franklin officials dispute the findings.

“We’re refuting all kinds of things in that report,” SUSD Superintendent Jack McLaughlin said Oct. 8. “There’s very little hard evidence. Our students are eligible.”

The section’s full report was obtained by The Bee after it filed an official request with the section under state laws governing public documents.

The report says Verner owns a home that several American Samoans stayed in over the last two years. Steve Seumaala, Jeff Seumaala’s brother, lived in the home.

Verner disputed that fact Oct. 9, but when confronted with ownership documents the next day, admitted the home is “one of 200” he owns.

Last week, the parents of two of the players now living with Gwen Seumaala filed a lawsuit against the section and Saco. The lawsuit alleges that the section’s investigators pried into private matters without authorization from American Samoan authorities or the consent of the teenagers, and that the investigators made inappropriate comments and asked leading questions.

“The lawsuit is a non-issue for the CIF,” Saco said last week.

Verner disagreed.

“They went over there and bullied and pushed those people around,” he said last week. “You can’t threaten those kids and tell their parents they could lose their eligibility in college if they don’t cooperate. That’s not right.”

The section and Stockton Unified School District have said they are willing to go to court to fight this. Should Franklin dispute the ruling, as expected, its next step is to appeal the penalty to the section’s board of managers. After that, it can appeal to the California Interscholastic Federation state offices, then into litigation.

For more information, read Wednesday's Bee or visit modbee.com.
Last edited by Homerun04

Add Reply

×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×